All scores →
Loading…
Loading…
Loading…

Shot selection: what makes a good shot good

By 4Basketball Staff · · 11 min read

A good shot is a matter of location, defender, timing, shooter and alternatives, not just whether it goes in. This guide breaks down the factors coaches weigh and how to judge a shot while watching.

Every fan has shouted at a television about a bad shot. A player pulls up with a defender in his face and the shot clock still above ten seconds, and the groan goes up before the ball hits the rim. When the shot goes in, the groan turns into confusion: was it a bad shot after all? This is the central puzzle of shot selection. A shot can be good and miss. A shot can be bad and go in. The result of a single attempt tells you very little about its quality, and the people who run offenses for a living know it.

What makes a shot good, then, is the probability that it will produce points, weighed against what else the offense could have done with the possession. That sentence sounds abstract, but it breaks down into a handful of concrete factors that coaches teach and that anyone can learn to see. Where was the shot taken? How close was the nearest defender? How much time was left on the clock? Who was shooting? Was he balanced and in rhythm? And what was the next-best option?

This article goes through those factors one at a time, explains how modern tracking has tried to put numbers on shot quality, looks at the traditional hierarchy of shots that coaches use, and ends with a guide to judging shots while you watch. It builds on the numbers in Expected points and shot quality: tracking-era basketball and the efficiency arguments in Points per possession: why efficiency beats volume, but it is written for the viewer rather than the analyst.

The basic unit: points per attempt

Start with the simplest way to compare shots: how many points, on average, does each attempt produce? A shot worth two points that goes in half the time produces one point per attempt. A three-pointer that goes in a third of the time also produces one point per attempt. A layup that goes in sixty percent of the time produces 1.2. A midrange jumper that goes in forty percent produces 0.8.

This is the foundation of everything else. A team has a limited number of possessions in a game, and each possession can end in only one shot, or in a turnover. Over a hundred possessions, the quality of the average shot determines the score. A team that can raise its average from 0.95 points per shot to 1.05 will win many more games, even if each individual shot seems to matter little. The idea is developed in True shooting percentage and effective field-goal percentage, explained, which shows how to fold threes and free throws into a single percentage.

The numbers are not the whole story, because points per attempt depends on who shoots and in what circumstances. The league-average value of a shot from a given location is a starting point. The value of that shot for a particular player, against a particular defender, with a particular amount of space, can be higher or lower. The rest of the article is about those adjustments.

Factor one: location

Location is the first and most obvious factor. Shots near the basket go in at the highest rate. Shots from the corners are the shortest three-pointers, because the corner of the arc is closer to the basket than the top of the arc, and they tend to be the most accurate threes. Shots from the top of the key and the wings are slightly longer and a little less accurate. Midrange shots in the long-two zone are the least efficient on average, for reasons explained in Why the midrange jump shot fell out of fashion, and why it is returning.

This yields the hierarchy that most modern coaches teach, which can be summarized in a short list.

  1. Layups, dunks and other shots at the rim.
  2. Free throws, which are not shots from the field but are produced by attacking the basket.
  3. Corner threes.
  4. Open threes from the wings and top.
  5. Midrange shots, with a distinction between open ones and contested ones.
  6. Contested long shots, very late in the clock.

The hierarchy is a guide, not a law. It describes the typical order of value, and a team that follows it has a better chance than one that does not. But it assumes the shots are available, and it ignores the shooter. A player who shoots poorly from the corner should not be taking corner threes just because the corner is the efficient place. The order of value changes when the person changes.

A shot chart can show where a player is efficient and where he is not. The basics of how to read one are in Shot charts: how to read where players score. A player's chart often shows surprising patterns: a guard who is deadly from the left wing and mediocre from the right, a forward who is great at the elbow and poor everywhere else. Coaches use those patterns to design plays that put a player on his best spots.

Factor two: the defender

The second factor is how closely the shot is contested. Tracking data classify shots by the distance to the nearest defender and have found, unsurprisingly, that open shots go in more often than tightly guarded ones. The difference is large enough to dominate the effect of location in many cases. An open three can be a better shot than a contested layup, and a wide-open midrange shot can be more valuable than a contested three.

This is the source of the coaching mantra that offense is about creating space. Screens, cuts, passes and drives all exist to produce a moment when the shooter has a step of room. The role of movement without the ball in making that room is covered in Off-ball movement: cuts, screens and relocation. A shot that is created by good movement and passing is likely to be a good shot. A shot that is created by a player forcing his way through traffic is less likely to be.

Defender quality matters too. A shot over a poor defender is better than a shot over an elite one, even if both are the same distance away. A tall defender, with length and the ability to contest from a distance, can reduce a shooter's chances more than the distance alone would suggest. This is one reason the same shot is better or worse depending on the opponent, and why offensive coaches often design plays to get their shooters matched up against the opposing team's weakest defender.

Factor three: the clock

Time changes the value of a shot in two ways. First, the shot clock affects the alternatives. Early in the possession, the offense has time to look for something better, so a marginal shot is a poor choice. Late in the possession, the alternatives vanish, and a marginal shot becomes the best available. A contested twenty-footer with three seconds left is not a good shot in absolute terms, but it may be the right shot in the circumstances, because the alternative is a turnover or a shot clock violation.

Second, the game clock matters. At the end of a quarter, a team may want to hold the ball for the last shot. When trailing late, it may want to shoot quickly. These choices affect what is a good shot at a given time. A three with twelve seconds left in a game when trailing by three can be the best option, even if it is not the best shot under normal conditions.

It is worth pointing out that "early in the shot clock" does not mean "bad." A quick shot in transition, before the defense has set, can be among the most efficient attempts, because the defense is disorganized. The first six seconds of a possession are some of the most valuable, as described in Transition offense: the first six seconds of a possession. The principle is that a shot should be judged by the circumstances rather than by a fixed number of seconds.

Factor four: the shooter

A shot is only as good as the person taking it. A player who makes 42 percent of his threes is a different proposition from one who makes 30 percent. A shot that is excellent for the first is poor for the second. This is a simple truth that is easy to forget when discussing shot selection in general terms.

The practical consequence is that shot selection is individual. Coaches talk about "good shots for him," meaning attempts that fall within a player's demonstrated strengths. A big man who has worked on his corner three has permission to take it. A big man who has not, does not. A guard who is deadly off the dribble from the left elbow can shoot there without hesitation. A guard who is not should look elsewhere.

There is also the question of rhythm. A player who has just caught the ball in a shooting position, with feet set and eyes on the rim, is in a better state than one who has caught it off balance. The mechanics of that state are in Shooting form: the mechanics of a reliable jump shot. A catch-and-shoot attempt usually has better results than an off-the-dribble attempt of the same distance, because the shooter is balanced and the pass has already moved the defense. The exception is a player whose gift is creating off the dribble, as discussed in Becoming a better shooter off the dribble.

The concept of "heat" falls under this heading. Players who have made several shots in a row feel hot, and the coaches' instinct is to keep feeding them. Statistically, the evidence for the hot hand is contested, and small samples can mislead, as explained in Small samples in basketball: when a hot streak is noise. A reasonable approach is to trust a hot player's judgment a little more and to keep him in shots that fit his skill, but not to let a streak turn a bad shot into a good one.

Factor five: the alternative

The factor that separates good analysis from superficial analysis is the alternative. A shot is good if it is better than what the offense can reasonably expect from passing, driving or resetting. A shot that is only 40 percent likely to go in may be an excellent choice if the alternative is a turnover. A shot that is 55 percent likely to go in may be a poor choice if a teammate is wide open for a better one.

This is why a team's best scorers are not always its best shot-takers. A great scorer who forces contested shots can reduce the efficiency of the offense, even if he makes a high percentage, because he skips better opportunities. A great scorer who understands the alternatives picks his moments and uses his threat to create shots for others. Both players may score the same number of points, but one makes the team better.

The same idea explains why passing is so valuable. A pass that creates an open shot is worth the difference between that shot and the one the passer would have taken. The mechanics and measurement of this are discussed in Ball movement and assist numbers: what 'good passing' looks like. Isolation play, in which one player works alone against a defender, has its place, but only when the isolation shot is better than what the team would get otherwise. That decision is covered in Isolation basketball: when one-on-one is the right play.

Beyond the shot itself: rebounding and transition

A shot has consequences beyond whether it goes in. A miss from the rim creates a rebound opportunity for the offense, because the ball tends to bounce close to the basket. A miss from three often bounces long, making it harder for the offense to recover it and easier for the defense to start a fast break. A shot from deep in the clock leaves the defense less time to set up, while a very early miss can lead to a break the other way if the offense has no one back.

Teams therefore consider not just the shot's chance of going in but also what happens if it does not. A shot with a lower chance of scoring but a higher chance of an offensive rebound can be as valuable as a more accurate shot with no rebound chance. Likewise, a team that wants to get back on defense may prefer shots that keep its players balanced. This is a reason that coaches do not simply tell everyone to shoot threes, and why the balance between offensive rebounding and transition defense is such a debated topic. See Offensive rebounding versus getting back: the central trade-off.

How tracking has tried to measure it

In the tracking era, analysts have built models that assign an expected value to each shot based on location, distance of the nearest defender, type of shot, and sometimes the shooter's own record. The resulting figure, often expressed as expected points or expected field-goal percentage, allows teams to compare the quality of the shots they take against the quality of the shots they allow.

Such models are valuable but limited. They can capture the measurable features of a shot, such as distance and defender proximity, but they struggle with context, such as the shot clock, the quality of the defender's hands or the player's rhythm. Two shots that look identical in the data may differ in subtle ways. The models also cannot fully account for the alternative, since the data do not show what the passer might have done. The result is useful as a guide and risky as a verdict.

A guide to judging shots while you watch

A viewer can apply a simple mental checklist.

Question What a "yes" suggests
Is the shot near the rim or a corner three? High-value location
Is the shooter open, with room to set his feet? Good chance of success
Is it a shot this player makes regularly? Good for him
Was the pass or the movement what created it? A product of the system
Did the offense have a clearly better option? If yes, the shot was a poor choice
Is the shot clock nearly out? Standards drop

Not every question needs a yes. A shot can be good with only a few of them. A contested fadeaway from a great scorer at the end of the clock is a good shot even though it fails most of the checks, because the circumstances left no better option. A wide-open shot from a poor shooter in the corner is a poor shot even though it passes several of them.

What to take away

A good shot is not defined by whether it goes in. It is defined by its probability of scoring, given the location, defender, clock, shooter and alternatives, and by its consequences for rebounding and transition. The traditional hierarchy of rim, free throws, corner threes and open threes is a helpful guide, but it must be adjusted for the individual and the moment.

For the fan, the lesson is to separate the judgment of the shot from the judgment of the result. Next time a player takes a shot that makes you wince, ask the five questions: where, how guarded, how much time, who, and what else. If the answers are poor on all five, your instinct was right. If the answers are mixed, the shot may have been the correct one, and the miss was just the part of the game that fell on the wrong side of probability.

Search more on this

Keep reading