Tournament expansion: from 8 teams to 68
The NCAA tournament began with eight teams in 1939 and now invites 68. This is the story of every major expansion, why each one happened, what it changed in the bracket, and how the women's tournament grew alongside it.
The first NCAA basketball tournament, in 1939, had eight teams. The field today has 68. In between sits a series of decisions, some made in a hurry and some after years of argument, each of which changed what a team had to do to qualify, how many games it took to win a championship, and who had a chance. The history of the tournament's growth is also a history of the sport: its television appetite, its power conferences, its small schools, and its constant argument over who deserves to be in March.
Expansion has never been a simple matter of more being better. Each time the field grew, someone argued that the regular season would be devalued, that the quality of the bracket would suffer, or that the tournament would lose the intimacy that made it special. Each time the field grew, the tournament became bigger, richer and more popular. This article follows the expansions in order, explains the reasons behind each, and asks what the pattern says about the event.
If you want the full story of the tournament's first decades, read the history of the NCAA basketball tournament. If you want to understand how a field of 68 is filled today, read how the NCAA tournament field is chosen. This piece is about the road between them.
The eight-team beginning
The NCAA's tournament began in 1939, an idea promoted by the National Association of Basketball Coaches and sponsored by the NCAA, partly as an answer to the National Invitation Tournament, which had begun a year earlier in New York. The first field had eight teams, one from each of eight districts, arranged in two regional brackets. Oregon won the first championship, beating Ohio State in a final played at Northwestern's Patten Gymnasium.
In those years, the NCAA tournament was not the most prestigious postseason event in college basketball. The NIT, played in Madison Square Garden in the biggest media market in the country, often attracted better teams. Some teams played both. The peak of this confusion came in 1950, when City College of New York won both the NIT and the NCAA tournament, the only team to do so. The next year the point-shaving scandals that involved City College and other New York teams damaged the NIT's standing, and the NCAA tournament, which was played in other cities, began to look like the safer and more respected choice. We trace the NIT's decline in the NIT: history and why it exists.
Growing in the postwar years
The field grew in small steps. In 1951 it doubled to 16 teams, and in 1953 it grew again, to 22. For most of the next two decades the number stayed in the low to mid-20s, adjusting from year to year as the NCAA balanced the number of conference champions against the number of independent schools. A typical tournament in the 1950s or 1960s consisted of a regional round, a regional final, and then the national semifinals and final, which came to be known as the Final Four.
Two features of this era are worth remembering.
First, the field was filled almost entirely by conference champions. Most conferences received one bid, the winner of their title, and independent schools filled in the rest. A team could win 25 games and finish second in its league and not be invited. This produced some of the best basketball of the era, because the best teams in a conference had to prove themselves in the conference race and tournament, but it also left strong teams at home.
Second, the NCAA tournament was still competing with the NIT. In 1970, Marquette, coached by Al McGuire, turned down an NCAA bid because of where the committee wanted to send the team, played in the NIT instead, and won it. The NCAA soon adopted a rule that a team invited to its tournament had to play in it, and the NIT's standing as an alternative for the very best teams faded.
1974 and the case for the at-large bid
The decisive argument for expansion came from a single game. In the 1974 Atlantic Coast Conference tournament final, North Carolina State, with David Thompson, beat Maryland 103-100 in overtime. The game is still regarded as one of the best the sport has produced. Maryland was one of the best teams in the country, but because the ACC was entitled to only one bid, the runner-up stayed home. A tournament that could not take the second-best team in the strongest conference in the country was hard to defend.
The following year, the NCAA changed the rules to allow more than one team from a conference, and the field expanded to 32. This was the beginning of the modern at-large system, in which the committee selects the best teams that have not won automatic bids, and it was the moment at which the whole question of who deserves to be in the field became a matter of judgment as well as of results. The mechanism is explained in automatic bids and conference tournaments and the judgment in the bubble.
Seeding and the climb to 64
The rest of the growth followed quickly. The field grew from 32 to 40 teams in 1979, the same year that seeding was introduced. Before then, teams were assigned to regions with little formal ranking. After 1979 the committee numbered the teams, and the idea that a team's seed was a measure of its season began to take hold. The field grew to 48 in 1980, to 52 in 1983, and to 53 in 1984. In 1985 it reached 64, and the format settled into the shape that most fans know.
| Year | Teams | What changed |
|---|---|---|
| 1939 | 8 | First tournament |
| 1951 | 16 | Field doubles |
| 1953 | 22 | Further growth |
| 1975 | 32 | More than one team per conference allowed |
| 1979 | 40 | Seeding introduced |
| 1980 | 48 | Larger at-large pool |
| 1985 | 64 | Four regions of 16 teams each |
| 2001 | 65 | An opening-round game added |
| 2011 | 68 | The First Four |
The 64-team field had a large effect. It created a perfectly symmetrical bracket: four regions, 16 seeds in each, 63 games to decide a champion. It ended the first-round byes that had been given to the top seeds in the earlier, uneven fields. And it created the 16 seed, a team that would, in the first round, face a one-seed. The immediate effect was dramatic: in the first year of the 64-team field, Villanova, an eight-seed, won the national championship. It remains the lowest seed ever to do so. We tell the story in the 1985 Villanova upset of Georgetown.
The 64-team bracket also changed how Americans engaged with the tournament. A symmetric bracket with 63 games was easy to print, easy to fill in and easy to turn into an office pool. The growth of that habit is discussed in March Madness in popular culture. The stage was set for the sport's growth into a national event.
Sixty-five and sixty-eight
For 16 years the field stayed at 64. Then, in 2001, the NCAA added a 65th team. The usual explanation is the creation of a new conference, the Mountain West, which earned an automatic bid. Rather than remove a team from the at-large pool, the NCAA added an opening-round game, played at the University of Dayton Arena, between the two lowest-ranked qualifiers. The winner went into the 64-team bracket as a 16 seed. The game was an oddity, a play-in that most fans ignored, and for a decade the number 65 remained a joke among bracket enthusiasts.
The bigger change came in 2011, after a public debate that reached the point of crisis. In 2010, the NCAA seriously considered expanding the tournament to 96 teams. The idea was supported by some administrators who saw it as a way to bring more schools into the event and to expand the revenue. It was opposed by many coaches and a large part of the public, who argued that the bracket was perfect as it was and that a 96-team field would dilute the quality of the opening rounds and turn the regular season into a formality. The NCAA instead chose a compromise: it expanded to 68, added three more play-in games, and called the new four-game group the First Four. That decision came with a new television agreement, reported at the time as being worth about $10.8 billion over 14 years, with CBS and Turner Sports sharing the rights.
The First Four has two kinds of game. Four of the eight teams are the lowest-ranked automatic qualifiers, playing for 16 seeds; the other four are the last at-large teams chosen, typically playing for 11 or 12 seeds. The structure is explained in the First Four: why there are play-in games.
One side effect of the change is a curiosity about the language. From 2011 to 2015, the NCAA called the First Four games the first round and the games on the Thursday and Friday the second round, and so on. In 2016, the old names were restored, and the round that starts the 64-team bracket is once again the first round. If you read an older article about the "third round" of the tournament and wonder which game it means, that is the reason.
The First Four also has a record of producing real surprises. Teams that began their tournaments in Dayton have gone a long way, and the best example is VCU in 2011, which won its opening game in Dayton and then four more to reach the Final Four. UCLA did the same in 2021. These runs showed that the extra games were not just a formality.
The women's tournament grows
The women's tournament has its own expansion story, one that is compressed into a much shorter time. The first NCAA women's championship, held in 1982, had 32 teams and was won by Louisiana Tech. It existed alongside a tournament run by the Association for Intercollegiate Athletics for Women, which ended soon afterward as the NCAA took over women's sports. The field grew to 48 in the late 1980s and to 64 in 1994. In 2022, it expanded to 68 teams, matching the men's format, and for the first time the NCAA allowed the women's event to use the "March Madness" name.
The women's expansion reflected the sport's growth, but it also reflected a recognition that the event deserved the same stage as the men's. We cover the format in the women's NCAA tournament and the longer story of the women's game in women's college basketball: from AIAW to NCAA.
Why the tournament keeps growing
Looking at the entire sequence, a few forces explain why the field has expanded so many times.
- Money. The tournament is the NCAA's principal source of revenue, and television contracts have grown with the size of the event. More teams and more games mean more inventory.
- Access. Conferences, especially large ones, want more of their teams to participate, and smaller conferences want to protect their automatic bids. Expansion lets both groups get what they want.
- Fairness. The 1974 example shows how a field that is too small excludes teams that plainly belong.
- Interest. Larger fields give more schools and fan bases a reason to care about the event, which builds the audience.
The forces that resist expansion are mostly aesthetic and practical. Critics argue that the regular season matters less when so many teams reach the field, that the extra teams are rarely competitive, and that the tournament's identity as an exclusive event is eroded. These arguments have been made at every stage, and each time the field grew they were not borne out by a decline in popularity.
Who gains when the field grows
Every expansion has distributed its benefits unevenly, and it is worth being clear about who gains. A larger field means more at-large bids, and at-large bids go disproportionately to large conferences, whose schedules produce the wins the committee values. The clearest illustration came in the first 68-team tournament, in 2011, when the Big East placed 11 of its 16 teams in the field, a record. One of those teams, Connecticut, won the championship after winning five games in five days at its conference tournament.
Small conferences gain in a different way. Their champions receive automatic bids no matter how large the field becomes, so the number of places reserved for them depends on the number of conferences, not on the number of teams in the tournament. As the field grows, the share of places reserved for small leagues falls, even though the number stays the same. The structure of the sport's conferences, and the way they have been reshaped in recent years, is covered in college basketball conferences and conference realignment and basketball.
This is why every proposal to enlarge the field is also a proposal about the balance of power. A bigger field helps the teams that are most likely to be on the bubble, and those are usually from the large conferences. Mid-major programs, which depend on automatic bids and on rare at-large invitations, have reason to watch such proposals with some caution, even though more places might seem to help everyone. We examine their position in mid-major basketball.
What expansion actually changed
It is worth asking what expansion did to the tournament's results. The answer is more modest than the debate suggested.
The top of the bracket barely changed. The best teams in the country were in the field at 32 and at 68, and the champion has almost always been one of them. The extra places went to teams at the margin: more at-large teams from the large conferences and a few more automatic bids. This is why expansion rarely changed who won. It mostly changed who got to play.
The bottom of the bracket changed more. Adding teams meant adding more low seeds and thereby more potential upsets. The 12 seed that beats a 5 and the 15 seed that beats a 2 are features of the 64-team era. Underdogs got more chances because there were more underdogs. We look at the mathematics in why upsets happen.
The bubble also changed. As the field grew, the number of teams on the margin grew, and so did the amount of attention paid to who was in and who was out. A field of 68 gives the committee more decisions to make, and it gives the media more material. The modern version of Selection Sunday, with its drama about the last teams in the field, is a consequence of expansion.
What to take away
The growth from 8 to 68 is a story of a good idea outgrowing its original size. Each step had a reason, a cost and an effect, and none of them destroyed what made the event worth watching. It is reasonable to expect that proposals to enlarge the field will come up again, since they have in every generation, and when they do it will help to remember the pattern: the arguments are familiar, the stakes are mostly financial, and the top of the bracket tends to stay the same.
For a look at how the bracket works today, see the men's brackets and women's brackets pages, which keep each year's finished bracket, and our March Madness hub for the rest of the story.