The NIT: history and why it exists
The National Invitation Tournament began a year before the NCAA tournament and once outranked it. This guide covers its history, how it works today, who gets in and what a postseason banner is worth.
Every March, when the NCAA tournament bracket is revealed, a second list is assembled a few hours later. These are the teams that were close, the ones that just missed, the regular-season champions who stumbled in their conference tournaments and the programs with winning records that the committee decided to leave out. They go to the National Invitation Tournament, the NIT, and for a couple of weeks they play a bracket of their own with a trophy at the end.
Casual fans tend to treat the NIT as a consolation prize, and for most of the modern era that is a fair description of how it is regarded. But it is also the oldest postseason basketball tournament in the country, it started before the NCAA event existed, and for a stretch of the 1940s it was considered the more important of the two. How it lost that standing, and why it still exists, says a good deal about how college basketball is organized.
This article walks through the NIT's origins, the years when it was the premier tournament, the events that shifted power to the NCAA, the way the tournament operates now and what it is actually for.
How the NIT began
The NIT was first played in 1938, in Madison Square Garden. It was organized by the Metropolitan Basketball Writers Association, a group of New York sportswriters who had been covering college basketball in the city's arenas and who thought the sport deserved a postseason of its own. The first field was small, just six teams, and Temple won the inaugural title.
The idea was simple. College basketball at that time had no national championship. Teams played their schedules, were ranked by the press and sometimes met in regional events, but there was no single tournament that settled the matter. The writers invited what they considered the best teams in the country to New York, put them in the sport's biggest building and let the games decide. New York was the media capital, the Garden was the nation's most famous arena, and the combination gave the event an immediate glamour.
A year later, in 1939, the National Association of Basketball Coaches helped launch the NCAA tournament, at first an eight-team event with Oregon the champion. The NCAA field was small, its early finals drew modest crowds and it lacked the Garden's prestige. For years the two tournaments coexisted, and it was normal for a team to be invited to both.
When the NIT was the bigger event
For much of the 1940s, many coaches and fans considered the NIT the more prestigious tournament. The reasons were practical. The Garden drew bigger crowds and more press coverage than any NCAA site, and winning in New York carried an aura that an NCAA regional in the Midwest or West could not match. Teams invited to both sometimes chose New York first.
The most famous illustration of this status is the 1944 tournament season, which produced a story that has become a piece of basketball folklore. Utah, invited to the NIT, lost in the first round. Then, when another team had to withdraw from the NCAA field after a car accident, Utah was invited to take its place. The Utes went on to win the NCAA championship. A team eliminated from the tournament many people valued more went on to become national champion in the other one, a reminder of how unsettled the idea of a national title still was.
The NIT also produced a unique double. In 1950, City College of New York, coached by Nat Holman, won the NIT and then the NCAA tournament in the same postseason, beating Bradley in both finals. No team before or since has won both in one year. It was the high point of New York college basketball, and it was followed almost immediately by disaster.
The scandal and the shift
In early 1951, a point-shaving scandal broke in New York. Players from several schools, including members of that City College championship team, were found to have accepted money from gamblers to manipulate the margins of games. Many of the contests in question had been played in Madison Square Garden, where gamblers had easy access to the college game. The scandal ended careers, closed programs' ambitions and badly damaged the reputation of the sport in the city.
Because the NIT was identified with the Garden, it suffered along with it. The NCAA tournament, which had begun to expand its field and its reach, moved up the ladder of importance. The shift was gradual rather than sudden. The NCAA event grew from eight teams to sixteen in the early 1950s, and television began to treat it as the national championship. Over the next two decades, as the NCAA field widened and its finals moved to larger arenas and bigger audiences, the NIT drifted into a supporting role. Our account of the history of the NCAA basketball tournament tells the other half of this story.
The last years of the NIT as a rival
The NIT did not collapse overnight. Into the late 1960s and early 1970s, strong teams still accepted its invitations, and in some cases they chose it over the NCAA tournament when given the option. The clearest example came in 1970. Marquette, coached by Al McGuire, had been assigned to an NCAA regional that would have forced the team to travel to a site far from home. McGuire objected to the assignment and took his team to the NIT instead, where Marquette won the championship. The episode drew attention to the loophole and contributed to a rule requiring teams invited to its tournament to accept the bid, closing the loophole that let teams choose.
That rule was a turning point. Once the NCAA required its invitees to play, the NIT could no longer compete for the best teams in the country. It had to rely on the teams the NCAA left out. As the NCAA field grew, first to 32 in the mid-1970s, then to 64 in 1985 and eventually to 68, the pool of teams available to the NIT shrank in quality. The history of that expansion is in tournament expansion from 8 teams to 68.
The NCAA takes over
By the early twenty-first century the NIT existed as a separate institution, owned by the group of New York colleges and the writers' association that had run it since the beginning, but dependent on a relationship with the NCAA that was sometimes contentious. In 2005, after a legal dispute, the NCAA acquired the NIT, bringing the tournament under its own management. Since then the NIT has been run by the same organization that runs the NCAA tournament, and its selection process, bracket and scheduling are handled by the NCAA's basketball staff.
The acquisition can look like a surrender, but it also ensured the tournament's survival. A tournament that depended on the NCAA's leftovers and that competed with it for television time and venue space had few long-term prospects. Under NCAA ownership, the NIT became a formal part of the postseason: the bracket is announced on Selection Sunday, the field is chosen by the same system that sets the NCAA field and the games are organized with the infrastructure the NCAA already has.
How the NIT works today
The modern NIT is a single-elimination tournament with a field in the low-to-mid thirties. The exact numbers have varied, but in recent years the field has been 32 teams. How a team gets in depends on a few routes.
- Automatic bids for regular-season champions. In recent years the NIT has given automatic bids to teams that won their conference's regular-season title but missed the NCAA tournament, usually because they lost in their conference tournament. This is meant to reward a full season of work and not just three days in March.
- At-large bids. The rest of the field is filled with the best teams not selected for the NCAA tournament, chosen by a selection committee using the same data tools as the NCAA field: the NET rating, quadrant records, strength of schedule and results against top opponents. The pool of teams that just missed the cut is the heart of the NIT field.
- Seeding. The teams are seeded, and the higher seeds host early-round games on their home courts. That is a major difference from the NCAA tournament, where early rounds are played at neutral sites for the men.
The title rounds were for a long time played at Madison Square Garden, the original home of the tournament, and more recently have been moved to other sites. For a description of the data tools used to select the field, see quadrant records and the NCAA selection committee's NET and college efficiency metrics.
Who plays in it, and why they accept
Most of the teams in the NIT field are what fans call bubble teams: programs with winning records that finished a few spots below the NCAA cutoff. If you want to understand the bubble, the bubble: who is in and who is out and Selection Sunday: how the committee works cover how a team falls on one side of the line or the other. A team on the outside might have a better record than a team on the inside; what matters is the committee's judgment of strength of schedule and quality wins.
The NIT field also includes teams from smaller conferences that earned their way in by winning their regular-season title, some of them with excellent seasons that were undone by a single loss in a conference tournament. For those programs, an NIT bid is not a consolation prize but a legitimate reward.
There is also a question of whether teams want to play. Invitations are voluntary, and a team may decline. Some power-conference programs with disappointing seasons turn down the NIT; others take it eagerly, treating the extra games as an opportunity to develop young players and to extend a season that would otherwise end in a conference tournament loss. The attitude varies by coach and by what the season has been like.
What the NIT is for
The most useful way to think about the NIT is as a postseason with three functions.
- Rewarding good seasons. A team that won twenty games and finished near the top of its conference should have something to play for in March, even if it was not among the 68. The NIT gives it a place to finish the season.
- Developing players. Extra games are extra practice. For a team with freshmen or sophomores, five or six games in March can be worth more than a month of drills. The extra reps also give coaches a chance to evaluate the roster for the following year.
- Preserving tradition. For schools in the New York area and for fans who grew up watching it, the NIT remains a living link to a time before the NCAA dominated the sport. That tradition is the reason the tournament has survived every change in the college landscape.
There is also an economic function. Home games in the NIT's early rounds generate ticket sales, concessions and local interest for schools that would otherwise be idle. For mid-major programs, a home NIT game can be the biggest crowd of the season.
The women's version and the other tournaments
The women's counterpart, the Women's National Invitation Tournament, or WNIT, was launched in 1998 and has become the principal postseason event for women's teams that just miss the NCAA field. It operates on a similar model, with a bracket of teams that fall short of the NCAA tournament and early-round games hosted by the higher seeds. You can see how the NCAA women's tournament works in our guide to the women's NCAA tournament format.
Other smaller postseason events have come and gone over the years, started by organizations that wanted to give more teams a postseason experience. Those tournaments have generally had shorter lives than the NIT, which benefits from its name recognition and its link to the NCAA.
Does an NIT title mean anything?
The honest answer is that it depends on the program. For a school with a long tradition, such as one of the New York programs that has been involved from the beginning, an NIT banner is a point of pride. For a mid-major that wins it, the title can be the biggest achievement in the program's history, and it often helps with recruiting and fundraising for a year or two. For a power-conference team with national aspirations, it is likely to be seen as a disappointment, a sign that the season fell short.
Fans should be wary of reading too much into NIT results as predictors of the next year. Teams that win in March bring back some players and lose others to graduation, the transfer portal and the draft. The advantage of the extra games can be real, especially for young teams, but it is hard to measure.
The NIT matters most as a window into how the sport's structure works. It sits at the edge of the NCAA tournament and shows who just missed the cut, which is often more revealing than the list of teams that made it. If you follow the bubble, you will learn the NIT field by watching who is left out. You can follow the postseason on our March Madness hub and the men's bracket page.
What to take away
The NIT began as a bold idea by newspaper writers and stood for a while as the premier tournament in basketball. It gave way to the NCAA tournament because the NCAA had the structure, the television partners and the single national field that the sport needed. What remained was a tournament that fills a real need: a place for good teams to keep playing, a laboratory for young players and a link to a different era. If you pay attention in March, the NIT is worth a look not as a second-best event, but as the part of the bracket that shows how thin the line between in and out really is.