All scores →
Loading…
Loading…
Loading…

Name, image and likeness in college basketball: how the new rules work

By 4Basketball Staff · · 10 min read

A plain explanation of how college athletes came to be paid for their name, image and likeness, what kinds of deals exist, how collectives and revenue sharing changed the picture, and what rules and risks remain.

For more than a century, the central bargain of American college sports was that athletes received a scholarship and the school kept the revenue. Coaches earned large salaries, arenas were built, television contracts grew into the billions, and the players who filled the arenas could not accept so much as a paid endorsement without risking their eligibility. The system was defended as amateurism, a principle that treated college athletes as students first. It was attacked as unfair to the athletes who generated the money.

That bargain broke in the early 2020s. Beginning in July 2021, college athletes were allowed to earn money from the use of their name, image and likeness, commonly shortened to NIL. In the years since, the rules have continued to change through court rulings, state laws, association policy and a major legal settlement. The result is a landscape quite different from the one that existed a decade ago, with new opportunities for players, new pressures on programs and new questions about how to keep competition fair.

This article explains the history of the change, the kinds of deals that exist, the role of collectives, what the more recent revenue-sharing model means and what rules still apply. Because this area is changing rapidly, we focus on the structure and the principles and note where details vary or are likely to change.

Why athletes could not be paid

To understand NIL, it helps to know the rules it replaced. The NCAA's rulebook defined an amateur as an athlete who did not receive payment beyond the value of a scholarship, which at various points covered tuition, room, board and later the full cost of attendance. An athlete who accepted money for appearing in an advertisement, signing autographs for pay or using his name to promote a business was in violation of the rules and could lose eligibility.

The system was justified on several grounds: that paying athletes would turn college sports into a professional league; that it would hurt schools without large budgets; and that fans valued the amateur ideal. Critics argued that the rules were out of step with the money in the sport. They pointed out that athletes in sports with large revenue, football and men's basketball, generated money for the schools while having little control over how they used their own names and images.

Several developments pushed the system to change.

Ed O'Bannon's lawsuit. O'Bannon, a former UCLA star from the 1995 national champions, discovered that his likeness was being used in a video game without compensation. He became the lead plaintiff in an antitrust case against the NCAA, filed in 2009. A federal court ruled in 2014 that the NCAA's restrictions on compensating athletes for use of their names, images and likenesses violated antitrust law, though the remedy it ordered was limited. The case planted the idea that the NCAA's rules were legally vulnerable.

State legislation. In 2019 California passed a law, often called the Fair Pay to Play Act, that would allow athletes in the state to earn money from their name, image and likeness. Other states followed, and the pressure on the NCAA to adopt a national standard grew. Many state laws took effect on July 1, 2021.

The Supreme Court. In June 2021 the Supreme Court ruled in NCAA v. Alston that the NCAA could not limit certain education-related benefits for athletes. The decision was narrow, but a concurring opinion by Justice Brett Kavanaugh questioned the whole basis of the NCAA's compensation rules and signaled that broader challenges might succeed.

The NCAA's interim policy. Facing state laws and legal pressure, the association adopted an interim policy that took effect on July 1, 2021. It allowed athletes to earn money from NIL, subject to state law and school rules, and stipulated that such compensation could not be used as an inducement to attend a particular school and had to be tied to real services or use of the athlete's name.

What kinds of deals exist

NIL is a broad term, and the deals that fall under it vary in size and structure.

  • Endorsements. A local business, such as a restaurant or car dealership, pays a player to appear in an advertisement or to promote the company on social media.
  • Social media promotion. Athletes with large followings are paid to post about products. A player's reach, not just his performance, determines the value.
  • Appearances and camps. Athletes may be paid to appear at events, sign autographs or run a basketball camp for young players.
  • Licensing and merchandise. Athletes can license their names and likenesses for products such as apparel, trading cards and video games, sometimes through group licensing arrangements in which a company pays a pool of athletes.
  • Collective-funded arrangements. These are agreements in which an organization raises money from donors and pays athletes for services such as appearances or content.

The sums vary enormously. A small number of players, especially stars at popular programs, have earned very large totals. Most athletes receive modest amounts, or none at all. The stars of the women's game, whose audiences and followings have grown sharply, have also become among the most marketable athletes in college sports. For the broader history of that growth, see women's college basketball from AIAW to NCAA and the modern game.

Collectives

The most controversial feature of the early NIL era was the rise of collectives. A collective is an organization, usually independent of the university but closely tied to its fan base, that raises money from donors and boosters and uses it to pay athletes. Some collectives operate by selling memberships or subscriptions, others through direct donations from wealthy supporters. Their stated purpose is to create NIL opportunities for athletes at a particular school.

The rules required that NIL payments be linked to a legitimate business purpose and not simply be a way to pay players to attend a school. In practice, the line between a service and a recruiting inducement proved hard to police. Collectives became a significant factor in recruiting and in the transfer market, because a program with a strong collective could offer more money than one without. This put pressure on coaches, who found themselves negotiating directly with prospects and their representatives about financial arrangements. It also contributed to the growth of agents and advisers in a part of the sport where they had not been prominent.

The settlement and revenue sharing

The NIL system established in 2021 allowed money to come from third parties, but not from schools. A later development changed that. In 2025 a federal court approved a settlement in a set of antitrust lawsuits, usually referred to as House v. NCAA, which resolved claims by former athletes who argued that they had been denied compensation. The settlement had several parts.

  1. Back payments to athletes who competed in earlier years and were affected by the restrictions.
  2. Revenue sharing. Under the new arrangement, schools that opt in are allowed to share a portion of their revenue directly with athletes, up to an annual limit set as a percentage of revenue that is adjusted over time.
  3. Roster limits instead of scholarship limits. The old caps on the number of scholarships were replaced with caps on roster size in many sports, giving schools more freedom to offer aid but limiting how many athletes can be on a team. For basketball, this meant a defined roster number, a change from the prior system described in how college scholarships work in basketball.
  4. Review of outside deals. A system for reviewing large third-party NIL deals was created, designed to ensure that they serve a valid business purpose and are not disguised pay for play.

The settlement was a landmark because it moved the arrangement from athletes earning from outside sources to athletes receiving compensation from the schools themselves. The legal details have been contested and are likely to be refined by courts and by new policies, so check recent reporting for the latest status. The economic context for the change is described in college athletics economics: revenue, television and the athlete's share.

How NIL changed basketball

The effects on college basketball have been felt in several ways.

Recruiting. High school prospects and their families now consider the financial opportunities available at each school. A program's ability to offer compensation, through a collective or directly, can matter alongside coaching, playing time and academics. That has changed the dynamic between recruits and coaches. See recruiting rankings for how those players are evaluated in the first place.

The transfer market. NIL and the transfer portal are closely linked. Players can move to a school that offers a better financial package, and programs can use money to retain players who might otherwise leave. The two changes arrived within a few years of each other, and together they have made roster building more like professional free agency. See how the college transfer portal works.

Eligibility and the draft. For players weighing whether to go pro or stay in college, the possibility of earning money in school has changed the calculation. A player who might have left after one year may remain for a second or third if he can earn a meaningful income and develop. That affects the traditional one-and-done pattern described in the one-and-done era.

Competitive balance. Schools with larger budgets and bigger donor bases have advantages. Smaller programs worry about losing their best players to higher bidders, a concern that has been a theme in discussions of mid-major basketball. Supporters of NIL argue that talent has always flowed toward resources, and that the new system simply makes the flow visible.

Rules and risks for athletes

Anyone considering an NIL arrangement should keep several points in mind. This is general information, not legal or tax advice, and an athlete or family should consult a qualified professional and the school's compliance office.

  • State laws and school policies differ. Some states restrict certain categories, such as deals with certain industries, and schools have their own rules about disclosure and reporting.
  • Contracts matter. Agreements may include exclusivity, termination clauses and obligations to deliver content. A deal that looks attractive can create long-term commitments.
  • Taxes. Income from NIL is generally taxable, and athletes may be treated as self-employed for some purposes. Planning in advance helps.
  • Scholarship and eligibility. Depending on the rules in force, NIL income may interact with financial aid or with eligibility, so check before signing.
  • Third-party advisers. Agents, marketing firms and collectives vary in quality and honesty. Read carefully, and ask questions.
  • Minors and high school athletes. Rules for high school students differ by state, and some states allow high school athletes to earn NIL income while others do not, with implications for later college eligibility. See high school basketball and eligibility.

The open questions

Several questions remain unresolved. Should athletes be considered employees of their schools, with the rights that come with that status? How will gender equity requirements, including Title IX, apply to revenue-sharing? How should the system treat sports that do not generate revenue? Can the association enforce rules about payments in a way that courts will uphold? And how will programs outside the biggest conferences compete? These questions are being argued in courts, in legislatures and in conference offices, and the answers will shape the sport for years.

A short glossary

The vocabulary of this area is easy to blur, and headlines often use the terms loosely. These are the main ones.

Term What it means
NIL The right of an athlete to earn money from his or her name, image and likeness
Collective A donor-funded organization that pays athletes for appearances, content or other services
Revenue sharing Payments made directly by a school to its athletes under the settlement framework
Pay for play Payment for playing or for choosing a school, which the rules have tried to separate from NIL
Inducement A benefit offered to persuade a recruit to enroll, which the rules prohibit
Roster limit A cap on the number of athletes on a team, which replaced many scholarship caps

Keeping these straight makes headlines easier to read. A story about a collective is about outside money. A story about revenue sharing is about money from the school itself. A story about an inducement is about a possible rules violation. Each has different rules and different consequences.

Reading NIL headlines with care

Large numbers attract attention, and the figures reported for individual players are often estimates from valuation services or from unnamed sources, rather than from published contracts. A reported "valuation" is not the same as money received. Deals may be structured over several years, include conditions or be reported at the maximum possible value. When you read a figure, ask whether it describes a signed contract, an estimate or a rumor. Ask also whether it covers a single season or several. A fan who treats every reported number as fact will often be wrong, and the same caution applies to claims about what a rival program is paying.

It also helps to ask what is being bought. A sponsor paying a popular player to promote a product is purchasing the player's reach. A school sharing revenue is paying for a roster spot and a role. These are different economic relationships, even if the same athlete receives both.

What to take away

NIL changed college basketball by acknowledging what had long been true: athletes create value and want a share of it. The first stage allowed outside deals, the second allowed schools to share revenue, and both have changed recruiting, transfers and the economics of the sport. For a fan, the practical effect is that rosters can change faster and that money is now openly part of the conversation. For a player or family, the practical advice is to treat any deal as a contract, to seek qualified advice and to keep in mind that the most valuable long-term assets are still health, education and skill. To follow how it plays out on the court, visit our college basketball page.

Search more on this

Keep reading

The NIT: history and why it exists

The National Invitation Tournament began a year before the NCAA tournament and once outranked it. This guide covers its history, how it works today, who gets in and what a postseason banner is worth.

4Basketball Staff · Mar 26, 2026 · 10 min read