The First Four: why there are play-in games
Why the NCAA tournament starts with four play-in games in Dayton, which teams play in them, how the format came to be, and what the teams that survived the extra game have done since.
On the Tuesday and Wednesday before the tournament everyone is watching, four games are played in a gym in Ohio. Eight teams take part. Two of the games decide which small-conference champions will become 16 seeds, and the other two decide which bubble teams get the last at-large places. The winners join the bracket and play on Thursday or Friday like everyone else. The losers are done, with a line in the record book and the odd distinction of having played in the NCAA tournament without ever being in the bracket people printed.
The First Four is easy to dismiss as a TV warm-up or a leftover from a compromise, and both descriptions have some truth in them. But the games are also a way of answering a real question: what do you do when the field you want to invite is larger than the bracket you can draw? The answer the NCAA reached, and the way it has played out in the years since, says a good deal about how the tournament balances tradition, money and fairness. It also produced a few of the most unlikely runs in the event's history, including a team that played its way into the Final Four after starting on the Tuesday before the first round.
This article covers where the play-in idea came from, how the four games are set up, who plays in them, the stories of the teams that went on to make noise, the criticisms of the format, and the right way to think about First Four teams when you fill out a bracket.
A bracket that needed a 65th team
A single-elimination bracket likes powers of two. Sixty-four teams fill a bracket perfectly: sixteen in each of four regions, with every team in a first-round game. For most of the 1985 to 2000 period, that is what the men's tournament had. The field was exactly the size of the bracket, and the committee's only job was to choose and place the teams.
The trouble started when the number of automatic bids grew. The tournament gives an automatic place to the champion of each eligible conference, and when a new league was formed and recognized, the count went up. The Mountain West began play at the end of the 1990s, and its automatic bid pushed the number of automatic places up. Rather than cut the number of at-large teams, which every conference with a bubble team would have resisted, the NCAA added one place. Starting in 2001 the field had 65 teams.
A 65th team meant an extra game. The solution was an opening-round game, played in Dayton, between the two lowest-ranked teams in the field. The winner became a 16 seed and faced a 1 seed on Thursday or Friday. The location was no accident: the University of Dayton's arena had hosted early-round NCAA tournament games for years and was known for its crowds and its tradition of hosting. Dayton became the home of the play-in game, and it has remained the home of the format ever since.
For a decade the opening-round game was a curiosity. Most casual fans had no idea there was a Tuesday game, and it involved two teams that were seeded last because they were weakest. It had no effect on the at-large teams that mattered most to the media, the bubble teams. The winner usually lost to a 1 seed, as 16 seeds almost always do. It did what it was designed to do, which was to make 65 into 64, and little else.
Why 68, and why a "First Four"
The decision that created the current format came in 2010, when the NCAA was negotiating a new long-term television agreement. There was serious discussion of expanding the tournament to 96 teams, which would have added a full extra round and brought in many more at-large teams, particularly from the large conferences. The idea drew heavy criticism from coaches, fans and commentators, who argued that it would dilute the event and weaken the importance of the regular season. The 96-team plan was set aside.
What the NCAA adopted instead was a smaller expansion, to 68 teams, announced along with a multibillion-dollar broadcast deal with CBS and Turner. The additional three teams meant three more games, bringing the play-in total to four. The 2011 tournament was the first with the new format, and the NCAA gave the four games a name: the First Four. We tell the longer story of how the field got from the original eight teams to its current size in tournament expansion from 8 teams to 68.
The design of the four games reflects what the expansion was meant to achieve. The added places were partly for at-large teams, which gave the large conferences more room on the bubble, and partly for automatic qualifiers, which kept the small conferences protected. The NCAA split the games between the two groups. Two of the four games feature the four lowest-ranked automatic qualifiers, which compete for places on the 16 line. The other two feature the last four at-large teams to make the field. The 68-team format still keeps a full 64-team bracket after the First Four, which is why the games are described as play-in games: they decide who gets the last spots in the bracket that everyone sees.
How the four games work
The mechanics are simple once you see the pattern. The selection committee ranks all 68 teams on its seed list, a process explained in how the bracket is built. The committee then identifies two groups of four teams.
| Group | Who is in it | What the winners get |
|---|---|---|
| Lowest automatic qualifiers | The four lowest-ranked conference champions | Two spots on the 16 seed line |
| Last at-large teams | The last four teams admitted on merit | Two spots on a seed line in the middle of the bracket, usually the 11 or 12 line |
Each group of four is split into two games, so there are four games in total. The two 16-seed games are played between teams the committee has ranked at the very bottom, and the two at-large games are between teams the committee saw as close to equal, since those teams are at the edge of the bubble. The winners take the spots set aside in the bracket, and their first-round opponents are known as soon as the committee announces the field. The participants in the at-large games are usually from the large conferences, because the conferences with the most teams usually produce the bubble teams. The games are played in Dayton, on the Tuesday and Wednesday after Selection Sunday.
A few points about the games are often misunderstood.
- The First Four teams are in the tournament. They are not a separate or lesser group: a win in Dayton is an NCAA tournament win and counts in the record books.
- The seed line for the at-large teams is chosen before they play, so the two teams in the same game are on the same seed line. The result decides who advances, not what seed they hold.
- Which game a team ends up in is a product of the ranking. Teams in the at-large games are, by definition, the last teams the committee decided to include. That makes the games feel like an extension of the bubble debate. We cover the committee's side of that argument in the bubble: who is in and who is out.
In most years the venue has been the University of Dayton Arena, which has hosted the opening round or the First Four for most of the time since 2001. One year the pandemic moved the entire tournament to Indiana, and the First Four was played there instead. The point of using Dayton is practical: it is a basketball town with a proper arena, and a Tuesday night game can draw a real crowd.
The teams that made the games matter
If the First Four had produced nothing but 16 seeds losing to 1 seeds, it would be a footnote. It has not. Several teams that started in Dayton went on to long and unexpected runs, and their stories are the main argument that the games are more than a formality.
VCU in 2011
The first First Four, in 2011, produced the most famous result. Virginia Commonwealth was an 11 seed that many commentators thought did not belong in the field at all. Its selection was one of the most criticized decisions of that year. The Rams beat Southern California in Dayton and then won a series of games against higher seeds, including Georgetown, Purdue, Florida State and Kansas. They reached the Final Four, the first team to do so after starting in the play-in round, before losing to Butler. The run, under coach Shaka Smart and built on a pressing defense, is a staple of tournament lore. It was also a vindication for the committee that put them in and a reminder that a bubble team can be a better team than its record suggests.
Dayton in 2015
In 2015, the University of Dayton itself was one of the last at-large teams, so the host school played in the First Four in its own arena. Dayton beat Boise State at home, then beat Providence before losing to Oklahoma. The run was short, but it gave the First Four a memorable home-court story and raised an obvious question about fairness, since a team playing an NCAA tournament game on its own floor was a rare situation.
Others in the early rounds
Other First Four teams have reached the second weekend of the tournament. Tennessee, as an 11 seed in 2014, beat Iowa in Dayton, won two more games and reached the Sweet 16. Syracuse, also an 11 seed, did the same in 2018, beating Arizona State in Dayton and then taking down TCU and Michigan State before falling to Duke. UCLA in 2021 beat Michigan State in overtime in the First Four and then won four more games, beating BYU, Abilene Christian, Alabama and Michigan, to reach the Final Four, where it lost to Gonzaga in overtime on a famous late shot by Jalen Suggs. Our piece on buzzer-beaters in March Madness tells that story.
The 16 seed who won
A First Four game can also launch a different kind of surprise. In 2023, Fairleigh Dickinson, a 16 seed, beat Texas Southern in the First Four and then beat top-seeded Purdue in the first round, only the second time a 16 seed had ever beaten a 1 seed. FDU's win is covered in the broader context of Cinderella runs by double-digit seeds, but it belongs here too: the team that shocked the field was one that had already played in Dayton two days earlier. The tournament had a team that had to win twice to be a favorite's opponent.
Is the extra game a burden or a benefit?
People like to argue about whether a team that plays in Dayton is better off or worse off for it. The truth is that the evidence is thin because the sample is small: a few dozen teams in a little more than a decade, with different seed lines and different opponents. But the arguments are worth understanding.
On the burden side, a First Four team has had a shorter preparation window. A team that learns it is in the field on Sunday plays on Tuesday or Wednesday, and then has a day or two to prepare for the first-round opponent and travel to that site. A team that plays Thursday had the same week to rest and scout. The extra game is also a physical cost, and in a single-elimination tournament every game is an extra chance to lose.
On the benefit side, a First Four team has already played a game at a tournament level, with the officials, the arena, the crowd and the nerves that go with it. It has had a competitive game in the week before everyone else plays one. A bubble team that has just won in Dayton also arrives in the bracket with momentum and, usually, with a point to prove. Many of the best First Four stories are about teams that were told they did not belong and played like it was an insult.
The best summary is that the format does not seem to help or hurt in a way that shows up clearly in the results. A better way to think about First Four teams is that they are the product of a ranking, and the ranking says they are weaker than the teams around them, but not by as much as the seed line suggests. That is a ranking-based question, and the answer in each case depends on the teams, not the format.
The criticisms, and why they persist
The First Four has detractors, and some of their objections deserve a fair hearing.
- Fairness to the bubble. Teams that are in the last four have a significant disadvantage compared with teams that were barely on the other side of the line. A team that is one spot better on the committee's list plays Thursday at a regular site, with a regular preparation window. A team that is one spot worse is in Dayton on a Tuesday, in a game that many fans do not watch. The difference between the two is a matter of one place in a ranking, as discussed in how the committee works on Selection Sunday.
- Round naming. When the format started, the NCAA first treated the First Four as the opening round and renamed the Thursday and Friday games as the second round. That confused fans who thought of the Thursday games as the first round, and the naming has been revised since to restore the more familiar labels. The episode illustrates how awkward it can be to add games at the front of a tournament that has long used a settled set of names.
- Treatment of the small conferences. The four lowest-ranked automatic qualifiers are, almost by definition, from the smallest or weakest conferences. Their champions are asked to play an extra game for the right to face a 1 seed. Defenders respond that the alternative was to leave those champions out, and that every automatic qualifier gets a chance to compete for a place. Critics respond that small-conference teams are asked to carry the burden of the expansion.
- Dilution. Some argue that the 68-team field includes teams that do not belong. The counterargument is that the First Four is a short extension of the bubble and that the tournament has always had to draw a line somewhere.
None of these arguments has been strong enough to end the format. Television likes the games, the host city likes the crowds, and the conferences like the extra places. In the meantime, the women's tournament adopted a similar structure when it expanded to 68 teams in 2022, which suggests that the idea has become the standard answer to the question of how to run a field larger than 64. For more on that event, see the women's NCAA tournament: format, regions and the growth of the event.
How to treat First Four teams in your bracket
When you fill in a bracket, a few practical principles apply to the teams that come out of Dayton. They are guides, not rules, and they are consistent with the broader approach laid out in bracket-picking strategy.
- Do not assume the First Four winner is exhausted. The teams have played a game, but the effect of a single extra contest is small and is overwhelmed by the difference in quality between the teams.
- Look at the seed line, not the route. An 11 seed that comes from Dayton is rated, by the committee, as one of the weaker teams on that line. But that is a statement about the margin between that team and the next, not a judgment of weakness. The ratings that sit behind the seed list are the better guide.
- Do not overreact to the VCU and UCLA runs. Those teams were notable because they were rare. Most First Four winners lose in the next round or two.
- The 16-seed winners are still 16 seeds. The 2023 result is a reminder that upsets happen, but a 1 seed beats a 16 almost every time, and the First Four does not change that.
You can see the full structure of the tournament, including the First Four, on the March Madness page, and the field in the men's bracket is the best way to see where the winners go.
What to take away
The First Four exists because of a series of compromises. A 64-team bracket was the ideal, a 65th team crept in when a new conference earned a bid, and a larger expansion was rejected in favor of 68. The four games in Dayton fill the last spots on the 16 line and the last at-large lines, and they give the bubble a final test and the smallest conferences a final hurdle. The format has its flaws, but it has also produced a Final Four team, several Sweet 16 teams and a 16 seed that beat a 1.
The best way to think about the First Four is as the final stage of the selection process rather than a first round. It tells you who was on the edge, and it reminds you that the edge of the field is not the edge of quality. The next time the tournament opens with a Tuesday night in Dayton, it is worth watching one of the games. You might see the first game of a long run.