All scores →
Loading…
Loading…
Loading…

Cinderellas: the greatest runs by double-digit seeds

By 4Basketball Staff · · 12 min read

The best NCAA tournament runs by teams seeded 10 or lower, from George Mason and Loyola Chicago to Saint Peter's, and what the pattern says about how Cinderellas are made.

The tournament sells itself on a promise: on any given night, a team nobody has heard of can beat a team everybody has. Most of the time the promise is kept in small ways, with a 12 seed taking down a 5 or a 13 seed hanging on for one afternoon. Once in a while it is kept in a way that people remember for the rest of their lives. A school with a small arena and a single television appearance a year reaches the second weekend, then the third, and its coach is suddenly on every channel explaining how it happened.

Those are the Cinderellas, and the word is used loosely. For this article we mean teams seeded 10 or lower, the double-digit seeds, whose results beat what the bracket said they should do. That group includes true long shots, such as 15 seeds that won two games, and 11 seeds that reached the Final Four, which is as far as any double-digit seed has ever gone. It does not include teams like Butler in 2010 and 2011, which were remarkable but seeded 5 and 8, and it leaves out the many mid-major teams that are good enough to be seeded in the single digits and win like it.

We will go through the Final Four teams, the deep runs that stopped just short, the 15 seeds and the two 16 seeds that beat a 1. Then we will look at what these teams had in common, because the pattern is more useful than the list. It helps to know the background on how the bracket sets up these matchups, which we describe in how the bracket is built, and the reasons games like these are possible, which we cover in why upsets happen.

The Final Four: six 11 seeds

No team seeded lower than 11 has ever reached the Final Four. Six 11 seeds have made it, spread across four decades. Each of them is worth a few paragraphs.

Year Team Where it lost
1986 LSU Final Four, to Louisville
2006 George Mason Final Four, to Florida
2011 VCU Final Four, to Butler
2018 Loyola Chicago Final Four, to Michigan
2021 UCLA Final Four, to Gonzaga
2024 NC State Final Four, to Purdue

LSU, 1986

LSU was the first of the group. Coach Dale Brown's team was an 11 seed that went through its region and reached the Final Four before losing to the eventual champion, Louisville. The 1986 run was the first time a team seeded so low had reached the Final Four, and it set the standard that the next five followed.

George Mason, 2006

The run that made the word Cinderella a regular part of the March vocabulary belongs to George Mason. The Patriots, from the Colonial Athletic Association, were an 11 seed under coach Jim Larranaga. They beat Michigan State, then defending champion North Carolina, then Wichita State, and then top-seeded Connecticut in overtime in the Elite Eight. They lost to Florida in the national semifinal, and Florida went on to win the title. What made the run striking was the list of names: a program from a conference that rarely got national attention knocking out three of the most established names in the sport. The run remains a touchstone for every mid-major program that dreams of a March like it.

VCU, 2011

VCU was the first team to reach the Final Four after playing in the First Four. Under coach Shaka Smart, the Rams used a pressing defense that created turnovers and tempo, and they beat Georgetown, Purdue, Florida State and Kansas. We describe the unusual route in the First Four: why there are play-in games. Their season, which began with widespread criticism of their selection, is one of the strongest arguments that the committee's bubble judgments are better at identifying quality than the public gives them credit for.

Loyola Chicago, 2018

Loyola Chicago, from the Missouri Valley Conference, was an 11 seed that won four games in a row, three of them by two points or fewer. The Ramblers beat Miami on a three-pointer by Donte Ingram at the buzzer, beat Tennessee on a late shot by Clayton Custer, beat Nevada by a single point, and then handled Kansas State in the Elite Eight. The team was a national story for a second reason as well: Sister Jean Dolores Schmidt, the team's chaplain, was in her late nineties and became a celebrity as the team won. The Ramblers lost to Michigan in the semifinal. Their coach, Porter Moser, later moved to a bigger job, a common sequel to this kind of run.

UCLA, 2021

UCLA is the odd entry on the list because of its pedigree. The Bruins are the most decorated program in the sport, with the ten titles of the Wooden era, which we recount in UCLA's dynasty: ten championships in twelve years. They were an 11 seed only because their regular season was uneven. They won the First Four against Michigan State, and then beat BYU, Abilene Christian, Alabama and Michigan before losing in overtime to unbeaten Gonzaga on a famous shot. A team with a great name and a modest seed is not a true Cinderella in the sense of a small program, but its bracket path is the same.

NC State, 2024

NC State is the most recent member of the group. The Wolfpack won the ACC tournament by winning five games in five days, which earned the automatic bid that put them in the field as an 11 seed. They then beat Texas Tech, Oakland, Marquette and Duke, and reached the Final Four before losing to Purdue. Their run depended heavily on a big man, DJ Burns Jr., who had a skill set unusual for a forward his size, including passing and footwork. It is a reminder that Cinderellas can be powered by individuals who match up awkwardly with higher-seeded opponents.

Almost there: deep runs that stopped in the Elite Eight

If the Final Four is the ceiling, the Elite Eight is the next floor down, and several double-digit teams have reached it.

  • Loyola Marymount, 1990. The Lions were an 11 seed and reached the Elite Eight in a season that began in grief, after the death of their star Hank Gathers during a conference tournament game earlier that month. They played a frenetic style and scored 149 points in a second-round win over defending champion Michigan, a tournament record. They lost to UNLV in the regional final.
  • Gonzaga, 1999. The Bulldogs were a 10 seed from the West Coast Conference and reached the Elite Eight by beating Stanford and Florida. They lost to eventual champion Connecticut. That run is generally treated as the beginning of Gonzaga's rise to national prominence.
  • Davidson, 2008. Stephen Curry's tournament run is one of the best individual stretches in the history of the event. The Wildcats, a 10 seed, beat Gonzaga, Georgetown and Wisconsin, with Curry scoring 30 or more in each of those games, and lost to top-seeded Kansas by two points in the Elite Eight.
  • Saint Peter's, 2022. A 15 seed from the MAAC, the Peacocks beat Kentucky in overtime, then Murray State, then Purdue, and reached the Elite Eight before losing to North Carolina. They are the only 15 seed to get that far. Coach Shaheen Holloway became a national figure, and the team's run was widely celebrated for the underdog nature of a school with a small campus in Jersey City.

Several other teams have reached the Sweet 16 as double-digit seeds, from the 14 seed Cleveland State in 1986 to Cornell in 2010 as a 12 seed. The Sweet 16 is, for a double-digit seed, a huge achievement, and the programs often return to the headlines as the subject of coaching job openings.

The 15 seeds: from Richmond to Princeton

The 2 vs 15 matchup is the most lopsided on the board other than 1 vs 16, and it is where the biggest shocks of the first round take place. Over the years the 15 seeds have won about a dozen times. The pattern has accelerated: the early upsets were isolated events, but since the 2010s 15 seeds have won more often than in any earlier stretch.

Some of the notable ones:

  1. Richmond over Syracuse, 1991. The first 15 seed to beat a 2 seed.
  2. Santa Clara over Arizona, 1993. The Broncos were led by Steve Nash, who went on to a Hall of Fame career in the NBA.
  3. Lehigh over Duke, 2012. The Mountain Hawks beat a Duke team that had been a heavy favorite.
  4. Florida Gulf Coast, 2013. The team known as Dunk City beat Georgetown and San Diego State, becoming the first 15 seed to reach the Sweet 16, with a high-flying style and a coach, Andy Enfield, who moved to USC soon afterward.
  5. Middle Tennessee over Michigan State, 2016. An upset of a team that was a popular pick to go deep, coached by the Hall of Famer Tom Izzo.
  6. Oral Roberts, 2021. The Golden Eagles, led by the high-scoring guard Max Abmas, beat Ohio State and Florida to reach the Sweet 16.
  7. Saint Peter's, 2022. Discussed above.
  8. Princeton, 2023. The Tigers beat Arizona and Missouri to reach the Sweet 16.

Looking at these, a few things stand out. Several of the teams played unusual styles or had a standout guard. Many came from conferences whose champion plays a lot of games against better opposition in the non-conference schedule. And in several cases, the 2 seed was one of the weaker 2 seeds, a team whose seed was ahead of its ratings. We cover the idea of seeds that run ahead of ratings in bracket-picking strategy.

The 16 seeds who beat a 1

Only two 16 seeds have ever beaten a 1 seed, and both did it in the era of the 64-team bracket. In 2018, UMBC beat Virginia by a wide margin, 74-54, in a game that was over long before the final buzzer. Virginia had been one of the best teams in the country, and the loss was a shock that reverberated through the sport. The Cavaliers went on to win the title the following year, a sequel that is one of the best redemption stories in tournament history.

In 2023, Fairleigh Dickinson beat Purdue, 63-58. FDU had begun its tournament in the First Four, and its win in the first round was close in a way that UMBC's was not. The Knights were undersized, among the shortest teams in the country, and they beat a Purdue team anchored by one of the tallest and most productive centers in the country. They lost in the next round to Florida Atlantic.

Before 2018, a number of 16 seeds had come close, and the most famous near miss, Princeton in 1989, lost to Georgetown by a single point. In roughly 160 games since the field reached 64, two upsets is still a tiny number, and a reminder that the odds are small but not zero. See the history of the one-seed for the full record.

What Cinderellas have in common

After going through the list, certain traits show up repeatedly. They are patterns rather than rules, and any of them can fail.

Guards and shooting

Almost every great Cinderella has at least one guard who can create his own shot and a roster full of shooters. Shooting is high-variance, and variance is the underdog's friend. A team that makes a lot of three-pointers can win a game in which it is outplayed on the glass and in the paint, because three points are worth more than two and the shots fall in streaks. Curry at Davidson, Abmas at Oral Roberts, and Custer and Ingram at Loyola are variations on the same theme.

Experience

Cinderellas are often older than the teams they beat. A mid-major with juniors and seniors has played together for years, while a power-conference team with freshmen and transfers may be less cohesive. The effect has weakened in the transfer-portal era, since everyone is more experienced than in the past, but it remains a reliable pattern.

A style that disrupts

A pressing team like VCU, a team that slows the game to a crawl, or a team that plays a rare defense, such as a zone, forces higher seeds into possessions they have not practiced against. The opponent has only a couple of days to scout, and the time pressure is greater for teams coming from a conference where they were rarely challenged. The 15 seeds that win often do so by changing the pace of the game.

A soft path

The easiest way to reach the second weekend is for the bracket to fall apart in front of you. A double-digit team that beats a 2 seed in the first round may face a 7 or 10 seed next, not a 1 or a 2. Several of the runs on this list were helped by the early elimination of the strongest teams in their region. The seed line is a sign of expectation, and when the expectation fails, the route gets easier for everyone left.

Peaking at the right time

Many Cinderellas arrive on a hot streak, having won their conference tournament. NC State's five wins in five days in 2024 is the extreme example. Momentum is hard to measure and easy to exaggerate, but a team that has played several close, high-stakes games has less to prove in March.

What happens after the run

The cultural story of Cinderellas does not end when the team loses. Coaches who lead these runs are often hired away, as happened with Larranaga, Smart, Enfield and Moser, and the schools are left with the tricky task of rebuilding. Players become household names for a few weeks, and some turn the exposure into professional careers. Universities often report increases in applications and donations after a deep run, and some administrators treat a tournament win as a form of advertising. That idea is often repeated, and it is plausible, but the data on the effect is mixed, and it is best treated as a possibility rather than a certainty.

It is also worth saying plainly that Cinderella runs are not typical of mid-major basketball. Most mid-major programs make the tournament only when they win their conference tournament, and most of them lose in the first round. Our piece on mid-major basketball covers how smaller programs approach the sport and why the deep runs stand out. The tournament keeps a place for them anyway, and the full list of unusual events is in tournament trivia.

Picking a Cinderella without going broke

A Cinderella run is what makes a bracket pool exciting, but picking one is hard. These principles help.

  • Focus on the 11 and 12 lines, not the 14 and 15. The 12-5 and 11-6 matchups produce surprises most years, and the history of those lines is laid out in the 12-5 upset: history, odds and the pattern.
  • Pick one or two, not six. Each double-digit seed you advance costs you points if it loses, and the odds are against any specific team.
  • Be wary of the narrative. The team with the best story is not always the best team. Check the ratings.
  • Remember the bracket structure. A Cinderella that wins in the first round still has to beat a good team in the second.

You can follow the full field on the March Madness page and see the bracket each year in the men's bracket view.

What to take away

Cinderellas are not accidents, but they are not predictable either. They are made of ordinary parts: a guard who can shoot, a roster of veterans, a style that disrupts and a bracket that cooperates. No double-digit seed has gone beyond the Final Four, and only six have reached it, which says something about how much has to go right. The journey from the first round to the national semifinal requires four wins against better-seeded teams, and the odds of that are small enough that it happens only once every few years.

For the fan, the lesson is to enjoy the surprise without confusing it for the rule. The tournament would be less fun without the possibility of George Mason or Saint Peter's, but it would also be less meaningful if those runs were commonplace. The tension between the rare and the expected is what the event is built on.

Search more on this

Keep reading

The 12-5 upset: history, odds and the pattern

Why 12 seeds beat 5 seeds about a third of the time, how the matchup became the most famous first-round upset, which 12 seeds are worth picking, and how the odds work out across four games.

4Basketball Staff · Aug 8, 2026 · 11 min read

The First Four: why there are play-in games

Why the NCAA tournament starts with four play-in games in Dayton, which teams play in them, how the format came to be, and what the teams that survived the extra game have done since.

4Basketball Staff · Aug 1, 2026 · 13 min read

Tournament expansion: from 8 teams to 68

The NCAA tournament began with eight teams in 1939 and now invites 68. This is the story of every major expansion, why each one happened, what it changed in the bracket, and how the women's tournament grew alongside it.

4Basketball Staff · Aug 19, 2026 · 11 min read