All scores →
Loading…
Loading…
Loading…

The Orlando Magic story: franchise history from 1989 to today

By 4Basketball Staff · · 11 min read

The Orlando Magic from their 1989 expansion start through the lottery luck that brought Shaquille O'Neal and Penny Hardaway, the 1995 Finals, the Dwight Howard years and the rebuilding that followed.

The Orlando Magic have a better claim than almost any other franchise to being the product of luck, and an equally good claim to being a cautionary tale about what luck can and cannot do. In their first 25 years they twice landed a franchise-altering talent in the draft lottery, once built a team that reached the Finals in only the sixth year of its existence, and then lost both of the cornerstone players who made that possible. The site's data lists zero championships, but this is a team that has been to the Finals twice and has had a surprisingly large share of the sport's memorable personalities.

If you want a one-sentence summary of the Magic's character, it is a franchise that has often been the second act to someone else's star. Shaquille O'Neal went on to win titles in Los Angeles and Miami. Dwight Howard became a champion in a purple and gold jersey. The team's best seasons were short and bright, and its worst were long and dull. But the arc has real interest, because the Magic's two Finals appearances each came with a team that was well built, well coached and, in different ways, very good at the things that the sport values.

This article follows the franchise from its founding in 1989 through the Shaq and Penny teams, the Tracy McGrady and Grant Hill years, the Dwight Howard era, and the more recent rebuild. For live results, the pages at /teams/nba/ and /standings/ are the right source.

Expansion in Central Florida (1989 to 1992)

The Magic joined the NBA in 1989, in the same wave of expansion as the Minnesota Timberwolves. Orlando had been a theme-park town for two decades, and its civic leaders believed a major-league team would help the city establish an identity beyond the attractions. The ownership group was led by Jim Hewitt, a local businessman, and the first general manager was Pat Williams, a veteran executive who had helped build the Philadelphia 76ers' 1983 champions and who brought a salesman's energy and a lot of connections. The name drew on the area's image as a place of wonder; the team's pinstriped uniforms became part of its early look. The context for how new teams get added is in the history of NBA expansion.

The first coach was Matt Guokas, and the first draft pick was Nick Anderson, a long, athletic guard from Illinois who would become the franchise's all-time leading scorer for a long stretch. The early Magic were an average expansion team: young, lightly talented and reliant on hustle. They played in the Orlando Arena, which opened in 1989, and fans came in large numbers for a team that was not yet good. Scott Skiles, a guard who set the NBA single-game record with 30 assists in 1990, and Dennis Scott, a sharpshooter drafted out of Georgia Tech, gave the team more offense in the early 1990s. But none of them were close to changing the franchise's fate.

That change came from a ping-pong ball. In 1992 the Magic, a team that had not been good enough to reach the playoffs, won the NBA draft lottery and the right to choose first. The pick was Shaquille O'Neal, a seven-foot-one center from LSU with the strength of a lineman and the athleticism of a forward. The draft lottery explained covers the odds in detail. Shaq was an instant sensation, a player who bent the sport's physical rules, and the arena filled up. He was an All-Star in his first season, and the team improved dramatically.

A second lottery miracle: Penny and Shaq (1993 to 1996)

If winning the lottery once was lucky, winning it a second time bordered on the absurd. In 1993 the Magic, who had finished with a record that left them with a very small chance of getting the top pick, roughly one in a hundred, won the lottery again. The draft's best prospect was Chris Webber, a powerful forward from Michigan, and the Magic selected him. Then, in a pre-arranged deal, they traded Webber to the Golden State Warriors for the third pick, a guard from Memphis State named Anfernee Hardaway, plus three future first-round picks.

Hardaway, whom everyone called Penny, was a 6-foot-7 point guard with the passing vision of a floor general and the size of a forward. He was graceful in a way that few players of his dimensions can be. Orlando already had the most imposing center in basketball. Now it had a lead guard who made the game look easy. Brian Hill, the coach, shaped the offense around them. Dennis Scott and Nick Anderson stretched the floor with perimeter shooting, and Horace Grant, a rebounder and defender who had won three championships with the Bulls, arrived in 1994 to supply the toughness the roster needed. The 1994 team made the playoffs for the first time, and the 1994-95 team won 57 games.

The 1995 playoffs were the apex. The Magic beat Boston in the first round, then faced Michael Jordan's Bulls in the conference semifinals. Jordan had returned from baseball in March, wearing number 45, and Anderson had stolen the ball from him late in Game 1, a play that led to a Magic win and a famously pointed remark from Anderson about what the number 45 could and could not do. Jordan returned to number 23 and the Bulls tried to climb back, but the Magic won the series in six games. The Magic then beat Indiana in seven games in the conference finals to reach the Finals, which they had no business reaching in their sixth season of existence. The Chicago Bulls' two three-peats tells the story of what that series meant for the Bulls.

The Finals was a disappointment. Opposing them were the Houston Rockets, the defending champions, led by Hakeem Olajuwon, who had been the best center in the world for years. In Game 1 in Orlando the Magic led by three points in the final seconds, and Anderson missed four free throws in a row; the Rockets tied the game with a three-pointer and won in overtime. They swept the series. For a team still learning how to win, it was an early and unforgiving lesson in what the Finals required. Olajuwon's career is the subject of Hakeem Olajuwon: career, style and legacy.

Shaq leaves, and the long unwinding (1996 to 2000)

In 1996 the Magic lost to the Bulls, now at their 72-win peak, in the conference finals, and that summer Shaq became a free agent. The Magic offered a long contract, and the Los Angeles Lakers offered something more: a stage, a city and a plan. O'Neal signed with the Lakers. The decision, a major event in the history of free agency, is a reminder that a franchise's most precious asset can walk out the door if the contract calendar and the player's priorities line up. The rules that govern this are covered in free agency in the NBA.

Penny Hardaway remained, but a series of knee injuries took away the explosiveness that had made him a star. Chuck Daly, the Hall of Famer who had coached the Pistons to two titles and the Dream Team to a gold medal, coached the Magic for two seasons, and the team stayed competitive for a time. By 1999 the roster had been stripped down. The Magic would need another route back to contention.

McGrady and Hill (2000 to 2004)

That route, they believed, was free agency. In the summer of 2000 Orlando cleared cap space and signed two of the most sought-after players in the market: Tracy McGrady, a long, silky scorer who had been playing in Toronto, and Grant Hill, an All-Star forward from Detroit with a reputation as one of the sport's most complete players. The plan was to pair them with Doc Rivers, who had been named Coach of the Year in 2000 after a surprisingly good season with a team of overachievers.

Hill's ankle did not cooperate. A surgery that followed his arrival turned into a long, painful string of complications, and he missed most of four seasons. McGrady, meanwhile, became a star. He won back-to-back scoring titles in 2003 and 2004 and had a flair that made him one of the league's most exciting players. In the 2003 playoffs the Magic led the Detroit Pistons three games to one in the first round and lost the series, a collapse that would be remembered in Orlando for years. Rivers was fired early in the next season. In the summer of 2004 McGrady was traded to Houston, and the team had a new plan.

Dwight Howard and the Finals trip (2004 to 2012)

The 2004 draft supplied the plan. With the first pick, the Magic selected Dwight Howard, a 6-foot-10 center who had gone straight from high school in Atlanta. He was enormously strong, a leaping shot blocker and rebounder with a smile that endeared him to fans. He was named Defensive Player of the Year three times, in 2009, 2010 and 2011, and was among the best big men in the league.

Stan Van Gundy became coach in 2007, and with the team's front office he devised a system that was far ahead of its time. He surrounded Howard with shooters at every other position: Rashard Lewis, a forward who could shoot threes, Hedo Turkoglu, a Turkish forward who handled the ball like a guard, Jameer Nelson and later Courtney Lee. With four players spreading the floor, Howard could dominate the paint. The approach anticipated the five-out styles that would become common, and it is related to what we discuss in five-out basketball: playing without a traditional center.

The 2008-09 team won 59 games, beat the 76ers in the first round, upset the defending champion Celtics in a seven-game series in which Boston was missing Kevin Garnett, and beat LeBron James's Cleveland Cavaliers in six games in the conference finals. The Finals matched them with Kobe Bryant's Lakers, who won in five. Orlando again won 59 games in 2009-10 and reached the conference finals, where it lost to the Celtics. In the next two seasons, as Howard's contract situation grew uncertain, the team fell in the first round. In 2012, after an on-again, off-again saga that lasted months, Howard was traded to the Lakers in a four-team deal. The Magic had won the lottery twice, drafted three of the league's best players, and could not keep any of them.

The rebuild (2012 to today)

The years after Howard were the franchise's hardest. The Magic missed the playoffs for six seasons in a row, a drought that ended only in 2019, and they tried a series of coaches and approaches. The team drafted and developed several promising players, including Victor Oladipo, Aaron Gordon, Jonathan Isaac, Mo Bamba and Nikola Vucevic, whom they acquired in a trade, but the pieces never fit into a coherent contender. Steve Clifford, who coached the team to its 2019 playoff appearance, was one of the steadiest hands during this stretch.

The modern chapter began in 2022, when the Magic won the lottery and selected Paolo Banchero, a skilled forward from Duke, with the first pick. He was named Rookie of the Year in 2023. With Franz Wagner, a European-trained forward, and a young group around them, and Jamahl Mosley as coach, the team returned to the playoffs in 2024, pushing the Cavaliers to a seventh game in the first round. Orlando fans, who endured the long years, finally had a team that looked like it could last.

Two Finals teams, two philosophies

It is tempting to treat the 1995 and 2009 Magic as variations on the same story, a young team with a dominant big man that came up short in the Finals. They were actually close to opposites. The 1995 team was built on individual talent. Shaq and Penny were both players who could break a defense on their own, and the supporting cast was assembled to give them room and to cover their weaknesses. When the Rockets, with Olajuwon, answered with a veteran team that knew how to play in June, the Magic had no second gear.

The 2009 team was built on a system. Van Gundy understood that a center who commands a double-team is most valuable when the players around him can punish the help, and he filled the roster with forwards and guards who could make threes at a high rate. The result was an offense whose strength was not any single player but the geometry of the floor. When Howard caught the ball in the post, a defender who left a shooter to help risked giving up an open three; one who stayed home allowed Howard to score. It was a clever idea, and for two seasons it made the Magic as hard to guard as any team in the East.

The cost of that system was its dependence on one man. When Howard's back and his contract became issues, the structure had nothing to hold it up, and the shooters could not carry the load alone. This is the deeper pattern of Orlando's history. The franchise's best moments came when it found a way to make the most of a singular talent, and its hardest came when that talent left. Whether the current group, built around two forwards and a deep supporting cast, is less vulnerable to that pattern is a question the next several seasons will answer.

The Magic's home and identity

The Magic's arena, now called the Kia Center, opened in 2010 and replaced the old Orlando Arena. The ownership has been in the DeVos family since the early 1990s, when Rich DeVos, the co-founder of Amway, bought the team; the family has kept the franchise in Orlando through lean years. Orlando is also a place where the national spotlight touches only briefly, and that has shaped the team's culture. The Magic have often been a developmental franchise, with a front office that prizes character and a fan base that appreciates the sport quietly.

The most natural rivals are Florida neighbors. The Heat, who joined the NBA a year earlier, are the closest, and the rivalry has largely been one of proximity and ambition. For their story, see the Miami Heat article.

Key moments

Year Event
1989 Franchise begins play in Orlando
1992 Wins the lottery; drafts Shaquille O'Neal
1993 Wins the lottery again; trades Chris Webber for Penny Hardaway
1995 Reaches the Finals; swept by Houston
1996 O'Neal leaves for the Lakers
2000 McGrady and Hill sign
2004 Dwight Howard drafted first overall
2009 Reaches the Finals; loses to the Lakers
2012 Howard traded
2022 Paolo Banchero drafted first overall

What to take away

The Magic's story shows how little a franchise controls. They could not control the lottery, which gave them Shaq and then Penny. They could not control a free agent's choice or an injured ankle. What they could control was the way they built around their stars, and in 1995 and 2009 they did it extremely well. Both teams were built with an understanding of space, shooting and defense that was slightly ahead of its time.

For the next step in understanding how a team like this operates, read about how trades work in the NBA, and check the scores for the latest on how the young Magic are doing.

Search more on this

Keep reading