All scores →
Loading…
Loading…
Loading…

Five-out basketball: playing without a traditional center

By 4Basketball Staff · · 10 min read

Five-out basketball puts all five players on the perimeter and leaves the lane empty. See how the structure works, what it demands of players, and what teams give up to get it.

For most of basketball's history, the lane belonged to the big man. A team had a center, and the center's job was to stand close to the basket, score from there, rebound and block shots. Everything else on the floor was organized around him. Guards fed him the ball, forwards crashed the boards beside him and the defense, in turn, was organized to stop him. The idea that a team might choose to have no one in the lane at all, on purpose, would have sounded absurd.

Five-out basketball does exactly that. It is an offensive structure in which all five players begin outside the paint, usually on or near the three-point line, with the lane left empty for drives and cuts. A center, if the team has one, becomes a perimeter player for the duration of the possession, catching the ball at the elbow or beyond the arc, dribbling, passing or shooting. A team without a center in the traditional sense might use five wings.

The approach has produced some of the most entertaining basketball of the last two decades, and also some of the clearest trade-offs. This article explains how five-out works, what it needs from players, what the offense gains and what it gives up on both ends of the floor, and how defenses have tried to solve it. It is a companion to our piece on pace and space, which explains the broader trend of which five-out is the logical conclusion.

The structure

The basic alignment is easy to describe. Five players stand around the arc, at the corners, the wings and the top of the key, or in some variations one player at the elbow. The paint is empty. The ball handler, who might be a guard or a forward, begins the possession by dribbling, passing or running an action such as a screen or handoff.

What makes this formation powerful is the geometry. Defenders are assigned to players who are far from the basket. If a defender leaves his man to help in the paint, he leaves a shooter open. If he stays home, the ball handler has an open lane. The offense is asking the defense to choose between two bad options on every drive.

There are a few common variations.

  • Five-out motion. The players move around the perimeter with cuts, screens and handoffs, but no one stays in the paint. This is a natural fit for teams that have versatile players, and it is built on the same logic as the offense described in motion offense.
  • Four-out, one-in. Four players stay on the perimeter and one player, usually a big man, plays near the basket. This is the traditional "stretch" structure and is more common than a pure five-out.
  • Five-out with a shooting center. A center who can shoot threes stands at the arc, pulling the opposing center away from the basket. This is the most common way teams get a five-out look without abandoning a center altogether.
  • Dribble-drive motion. An offense that places players around the arc and encourages the ball handler to attack the rim, with the others spaced for kick-out passes. It was popular in college basketball, where coaches such as Vance Walberg and John Calipari built offenses around its principles.

Each of these versions shares the commitment to emptying the lane. They differ in how much structure they use and in how the big man is involved.

How the offense works

Once the lane is empty, the offense has three main tools: the drive, the cut and the pass. The drive is the most direct. A ball handler who gets past his defender, even by a half step, finds a clear path to the basket. The defense must rotate to stop him, and the rotation leaves someone open.

The cut is the second tool. In a five-out set, players away from the ball can cut to the basket whenever their defender looks away. The backdoor cut, in which a player cuts behind an overplaying defender, is especially effective because no help defender waits in the lane to stop it. Our article on off-ball movement describes the skills involved.

The pass is the third. With five players spread around the arc, any pass is a potential catch-and-shoot three. A drive-and-kick is the staple: the ball handler drives, the defense collapses, and the ball goes to an open shooter. The best five-out teams can make this pass multiple times in a possession, with each pass creating a new open shot.

In addition to those three, five-out offenses often use screens and handoffs, because the same logic applies. A pick and roll between a guard and a shooting big is more dangerous when no other defender is in the lane to help. A dribble handoff, as described in the dribble handoff, puts a defender at a disadvantage without the ball ever being in the paint. If you want to see the strongest version of this idea, look at the way a good team uses the pick and roll when all five players are threats from outside.

Five-out basketball turns every help defender into a gambler. If he helps, he gives up a shot. If he does not, he gives up a drive.

What it demands of players

The five-out approach depends on a roster with specific abilities. The first requirement is shooting. If a defender can safely ignore a player, that player's presence in the formation does not create space. In a pure five-out lineup, every player must be a credible shooter, or at least a credible enough threat to force a defender to stay close. This is easier at guard and wing than at big man, which is why finding a shooting center is a prized skill.

The second is ball handling and passing. Players must be able to put the ball on the floor when a defender closes out, and to pass to a teammate when the defense collapses. A big man who can make a pass from the perimeter, or a forward who can run a handoff, is a major asset. The five-out approach rewards players who can do several things, and punishes specialists whose only skill is one that works in the paint.

The third is defensive versatility. If all five players on the floor are small or mobile, the lineup needs defenders who can switch onto multiple positions. A team with no rim protector must defend the basket by other means, such as quick rotations, active hands and great closeouts. The best five-out teams are built around players who can guard several positions.

The fourth is decision-making. Five-out basketball is fast and spread, and the players have to make good decisions on the move. They need to know when to drive, when to pass, when to shoot and when to cut. That demands training and repetition, as well as the ability to read the defense.

This is a lot to ask, and few rosters have all of those traits. A team may use five-out lineups in stretches, when the personnel allows, rather than as a base. In many cases, coaches limit five-out minutes to specific situations, such as when they need offense late in a game.

Famous examples

The idea of playing without a traditional center did not begin with analytics. Coaches have long experimented with small lineups when they had the personnel to do it. In the middle of the 2000s, Mike D'Antoni's Phoenix Suns used a very small lineup around Steve Nash, with forwards playing in the center spot at times. Their speed and shooting made them a difficult opponent, even though they lacked a dominant big man. They are discussed in more detail in our piece on pace and space.

The Miami Heat of the early 2010s, with LeBron James, Dwyane Wade and Chris Bosh, used lineups in which James played power forward and Bosh played center, giving them speed and shooting that most opponents could not match. They won two championships in this period. Their approach showed that a team could win without a conventional center when it had a player of James's versatility.

The Golden State Warriors took the idea further. In the 2015 NBA Finals, they changed their starting lineup in the middle of the series, adding a wing and moving a forward, Draymond Green, into a role that effectively made him the center. The shift gave them more speed and shooting, and they went on to win the series against Cleveland. In the years that followed, the Warriors made a lineup with Green at center, surrounded by shooters, a signature weapon. The lineup was nicknamed the "Death Lineup" for the damage it did to opponents.

Houston, under D'Antoni's coaching later in the decade, also moved toward lineups without a conventional center, using forwards at the five and surrounding James Harden with shooters. The experiment showed how far a team could go with the philosophy, as well as where it ran into trouble when faced with the better rebounding and rim protection of other teams. You can read about the broader era in the 2010s.

What it gives up

The most important cost is rebounding. When no one is near the basket, there are fewer players in position to grab missed shots. The defense may also struggle to rebound, because the smaller players cannot box out larger opponents. Five-out teams often accept this trade, reasoning that the extra points from spacing outweigh the lost rebounds, but it is a real trade-off. The offensive version of this dilemma is explained in offensive rebounding versus getting back, and the defensive side is in defensive rebounding.

The second cost is rim protection. A team without a big man in the paint has a hard time stopping layups. Opponents who attack the basket aggressively can score easily, unless the five-out team can switch, rotate or take away drives before they begin. Our article on rim protection shows what is lost when the shot-blocker leaves the floor.

The third is the loss of post scoring. In a five-out set, no one is in a position to receive the ball on the block, which means the offense cannot punish a smaller defender with a post-up. If an opponent switches onto a mismatch, the offense may be unable to take advantage. Some teams solve this by bringing the mismatch to the post for a possession and then returning to the five-out structure.

The fourth is physical wear. Five-out basketball asks players to run, space and attack constantly. Players who play it for long stretches need the stamina to keep it up. The style is less forgiving of fatigue, since a tired player is a defensive liability.

How defenses respond

Defenses have devised several ways to deal with five-out lineups. The first is to pack the paint. A defender who stays near the basket even when his man is on the perimeter takes away drives, accepting the risk of an open three. This works against teams that shoot poorly and fails against teams that shoot well. It depends on who is in the lineup.

The second is to switch. If every defender can guard multiple positions, the defense can handle screens and handoffs without leaving shooters. This is the logic of switch-everything defense, and it is one of the main reasons teams value versatile defenders.

The third is to use a zone. A zone covers space rather than players, so the empty-lane structure of five-out is less effective against it. The offense must adapt by finding gaps, passing quickly and making threes. For the principles, see zone defense. Teams that lack shooting find zones a good answer to a five-out lineup.

The fourth is to dare the offense to shoot. A defense may decide that a particular player is a poor shooter and ignore him, leaving a free defender to help. This is how defenses deal with five-out lineups that include a non-shooter. The offense must then either replace the player or use him as a screener.

Finally, the defense can try to take away the ball handler's first move. If a guard cannot get by his defender, the structure becomes less dangerous. Strong on-ball defenders, who can stay in front of a driver without help, are valuable against five-out sets for this reason.

Not a revolution, a toolbox

It would be easy to conclude that five-out basketball has replaced the traditional game. It has not. Most teams still use a mix of lineups, and many successful teams have a big man who plays near the basket. The reason is that five-out has weaknesses, and good opponents will exploit them. The approach works best as a tool that a coach can deploy against certain teams or in certain situations.

The better way to think about it is as the extreme end of a spectrum. At one end is the old-fashioned post-centered offense. At the other is the pure five-out. Most teams live somewhere between, with a center who can both protect the rim and shoot, wings who can switch, and a ball handler who can create. The question is how far to move toward the five-out end, and the answer depends on personnel.

For a look at the opposite end of the spectrum, see our article on post-up basketball. The history of the game has been a long argument between those two ideas, and the argument is not over.

What to take away

Five-out basketball empties the lane to create space for drives, cuts and kick-outs. It demands shooting at every position, ball handling and passing from big men and defensive versatility, and it costs a team in rebounding and rim protection. It works best when the personnel fit, and it is often most effective as one option among many.

Next time you see a team with no one near the basket, ask two questions: what does the defense do when a guard drives, and who gets the rebound if the shot misses? The answers show both the strength and the price of the approach. To see which teams use spacing most effectively, explore the NBA teams and compare how they are built.

Search more on this

Keep reading