The NBA draft lottery: odds, flattening and how it works
How the NBA draft lottery works, from the 1985 coin-flip replacement to the weighted ping-pong ball draw and the flattening of the odds, with the arithmetic behind the combinations and a few famous upsets.
Each spring a small group of people sits in a room with a machine, a set of numbered ping-pong balls and a rulebook. A few minutes later, the league announces which teams will pick first, second, third and fourth in the draft. The result changes the future of the teams involved, sometimes for a decade, and the process that produces it is more carefully designed than most fans realize. The lottery is a piece of mechanism design: a system built to balance two goals that pull against each other.
This article explains how the lottery works and why it looks the way it does. We begin with what came before it, a coin flip that taught the league a lesson in 1983 and 1984, then describe the mechanics of the draw and the arithmetic of the combinations. We explain what the 2019 reform, usually called flattening, changed and why, show the odds that follow from it, and look at the famous lotteries in which the longshot won. We close with the larger question the system tries to answer: how do you help bad teams without rewarding them for being bad?
As always, a note on rules that change. The league has revised the lottery several times, and it may do so again. We describe the structure that has been in place in recent seasons and the principles that guide it, and we suggest checking the league's current rules for any particular year.
The problem the lottery solves
The draft exists to help weak teams. Under the original design, teams choose in reverse order of their records, so the team with the worst record picks first. The reasoning is straightforward: a new player on a rookie contract is cheap and talented, and giving the best prospects to the worst teams should, over time, keep the league balanced.
The design has a flaw. If the worst team is guaranteed the first pick, then losing becomes valuable. A team that is out of the race may conclude that winning a few more games would cost it a chance at a star, and it may rest its players or field a weak lineup on purpose. The behavior is called tanking, and it is bad for the league, for the fans who buy tickets and for the integrity of the game. The lottery is the league's response. It breaks the direct link between losing and picking first, so the reward for finishing last is a better chance and not a guarantee.
Before the lottery existed, the league used a simpler device. The team with the worst record in each conference took part in a coin flip, and the winner of the flip got the first pick. The system produced some memorable results. In 1979 the coin flip between Chicago and Los Angeles, the latter holding a pick it had acquired in a trade with New Orleans, was won by the Lakers, who selected Magic Johnson. Our piece on Bird and Magic tells what followed.
The coin flip also produced the situation that ended it. Houston won the flip in 1983 and drafted Ralph Sampson, then finished the 1983-84 season with the worst record in the West, won the flip again, and drafted Hakeem Olajuwon. Many observers believed the Rockets had played to lose in 1984, and whether or not that was true, the appearance was a problem. The league decided to introduce a lottery for 1985.
The first lotteries
The 1985 lottery gave every team that missed the playoffs an equal chance at the first pick. The first winner was New York, which used the pick on Patrick Ewing. An equal chance for every non-playoff team removed the incentive to finish last, but it created a different problem: a team that had been far worse than any other had the same chance as a team that narrowly missed the playoffs, and many felt that was unfair to the teams in greatest need.
The league moved toward weighting. By 1990 the system gave the worst teams a larger share of the combinations, and the odds were adjusted again in the 1990s. The pivotal moment came in 1993. Orlando, which had won the lottery in 1992 and selected Shaquille O'Neal, won it again in 1993 with a low chance, choosing Chris Webber and trading him to Golden State for Anfernee Hardaway and future picks. Two wins in a row for one franchise, the second with long odds, prompted the league to change the weights for 1994 to favor the teams with the worst records. That system, in which the worst team had a 25 percent chance at the first pick, stayed in place for 25 years.
How the draw works
The mechanics of the draw have been stable in outline for a long time. Fourteen teams take part: the ones that did not make the playoffs, including those eliminated in the play-in tournament. Each is assigned a number of four-digit combinations. The numbers on the balls run from 1 to 14, and four balls are drawn from the machine. Because the order of the four balls does not matter, the number of distinct combinations is the number of ways to choose four from fourteen, which is 1,001.
The league assigns 1,000 of the 1,001 combinations to the teams, in proportion to the odds each should have. One combination is left unassigned. If that combination is drawn, it is set aside and the balls are drawn again. That detail makes the arithmetic clean, because each team's number of combinations out of 1,000 translates directly to its percentage chance.
The process is run four times for the draw of the first four picks. After a combination is drawn for the first pick, the team that holds it takes the first selection and any other combination that includes the winning team is removed from later draws. This continues until picks one through four are filled. The remaining ten lottery teams are then slotted into picks five through fourteen in reverse order of their records. Picks fifteen to thirty go to the playoff teams, in order of record, and the second round follows its own order.
The drawing is conducted under the supervision of representatives of an independent accounting firm, and it is done privately before the results are announced on a televised show, so that the process is secure and the reveal can be made in order. The televised ceremony is an exercise in presentation, and the real work is the supervised draw.
Flattening
For a quarter of a century after 1994, the lottery gave the team with the worst record 250 of the 1,000 combinations, a 25 percent chance of the first pick. The second-worst team had 199 combinations, and the chances dropped from there. The structure also guaranteed that the worst team could do no worse than fourth, because only the first three picks were drawn.
By the late 2010s, the league was concerned. Tanking was widely discussed, and some teams had been accused of building their rosters to lose. The league's response, adopted for the 2019 lottery, is called flattening. It changed the odds in two ways.
- The worst teams share the top odds. Under the new system, the three teams with the worst records each have the same chance of the first pick, 14 percent. The advantage of finishing last, as opposed to third from last, is gone.
- The lottery draws the top four picks. Instead of three picks, the lottery now determines four, which means the worst team can fall to fifth, not just fourth.
The result is that the gap between the worst record and the next few is much smaller. The incentive to be the very worst team is reduced, because a team that loses a few extra games gains little in expected draft position. The overall effect is to make the lottery a more open draw with the same format.
The odds
The chances for the first pick under the flattened system are as follows. They are the odds for each position among the fourteen lottery teams, ranked from the worst record to the best.
| Worst-record rank | Chance of the first pick |
|---|---|
| 1st, 2nd and 3rd | 14.0 percent each |
| 4th | 12.5 percent |
| 5th | 10.5 percent |
| 6th | 9.0 percent |
| 7th | 7.5 percent |
| 8th | 6.0 percent |
| 9th | 4.5 percent |
| 10th | 3.0 percent |
| 11th | 2.0 percent |
| 12th | 1.5 percent |
| 13th | 1.0 percent |
| 14th | 0.5 percent |
These chances add up to 100 percent, and they correspond to the 1,000 combinations, with 140 combinations for each of the three worst teams down to five combinations for the 14th. The worst team can drop no lower than fifth. The team with the best record among lottery teams has a chance of only half a percent at the top pick, but it can still move into the top four in rare cases.
The shape of the table tells you the philosophy. The odds fall gradually from the worst to the best, with a wide plateau at the top. A bad team still has the best chance, but a mediocre one has a real shot, and no team can count on a high pick.
Another way to see the point is to compare the incentives. Under the old system, a team in the last few games of the season that had to choose between winning and losing faced a large difference in expected outcome: finishing last gave a 25 percent chance, and finishing second last gave 20 percent. Under the new system, the corresponding difference is zero for the bottom three, and small beyond them. The league has also considered other measures to discourage deliberately losing, and the rules around the lottery are revisited from time to time. Our article on the business of the draft looks at how teams value picks.
The longshots
The lottery's drama comes from the possibility that a team with long odds wins. It has happened often enough that it is part of the league's folklore.
- Orlando, 1992 and 1993. The Magic won in consecutive years, the second time with odds of about one and a half percent, which led directly to the 1994 reform.
- Chicago, 2008. The Bulls entered the lottery with a small chance, under two percent, and won, taking Derrick Rose, who became the youngest player to win the league's Most Valuable Player award a few years later.
- Cleveland, 2011, 2013 and 2014. The Cavaliers won three of four lotteries, a run that supplied a core of young players and that, along with LeBron James's return in 2014, shaped the team that reached four consecutive Finals. We tell that story in Warriors versus Cavaliers.
These stories are memorable because they are exceptions. In most years the team with the best odds or one of the top three picks the first player. But the exceptions explain why the system has the support it does: the possibility of a longshot keeps every team in the draw and makes the lottery a drama and not a formality.
It is also worth remembering that a first pick is not a guarantee of success. Our article on the greatest NBA drafts shows how often the top pick is one of several players who define a class, and how often the best players come from lower down.
Who gets the pick
The lottery decides slots, and the slots are assets that can be traded. A team's pick is determined by its record, but the right to use it may belong to another team through a previous trade. When the lottery is drawn, it is the position that is decided, and the team that owns the pick at that time is the one that selects. Many picks are traded years in advance, sometimes with conditions, such as "the pick transfers unless it falls in the top ten." These conditions can make the lottery matter even to teams that do not hold their own picks, since the outcome can decide whether a protected pick conveys or stays.
Ties in the standings are resolved by a random draw conducted before the lottery. If two teams have the same record, the draw decides which of them is treated as having the worse record for the purposes of odds. Our article on tie-breakers in the NBA standings covers how the regular-season ranking is built.
The women's league has its own lottery, with a different structure suited to a league with fewer teams. For that comparison, see our guide to how the WNBA draft works.
Does the lottery work?
The honest answer is that it works partly. A lottery cannot remove the incentive to lose. It can only dilute it. A team with a poor record still has the best odds, even if they are shared, and many observers believe that some teams continue to prioritize development over winning. The league's repeated reforms are an acknowledgment that the problem has not gone away.
At the same time, the lottery has several advantages. It prevents a team from locking in the first pick, which reduces the most extreme incentives. It creates a public event that builds interest in the draft. It rewards no one for failure with certainty, which is fairer to the teams that are bad through no choice of their own, such as those hit by injuries. And it gives each of the fourteen teams a real, if small, reason to look forward to the draw.
There is also a deeper point about design. Any rule that gives a prize to the worst performers creates an incentive to be one of them. The league's answer is to make the prize uncertain and to spread it across more teams, so that the expected value of deliberate losing is smaller than the cost of the lost games, in revenue and reputation. Whether that calculation works in practice depends on how each team's ownership weighs the future against the present, and the debate continues.
What to take away
The lottery is a compromise. It replaced a coin flip that rewarded the worst teams and invited accusations of tanking. It started as an equal-chance draw, became a weighted one after the Orlando results of the early 1990s, and was flattened in 2019 to reduce the advantage of losing. The mechanism is simple in outline: fourteen teams, fourteen balls, four drawn, and 1,001 combinations of which 1,000 are assigned. The odds fall from 14 percent for the three worst teams to half a percent for the best of the lottery teams.
When you watch the draw, you can read it yourself. Know which teams have the 14 percent odds and which have the one and two percent odds. Remember that picks five through fourteen follow the standings once the first four are set. And when a longshot jumps to the top, remember Orlando in 1993 and Chicago in 2008, because it has happened before and it will happen again.
For more on how a team gets from the draft to the roster, see our article on rookies and the rookie scale. The NBA section and the standings show the teams in the race, and the teams directory lets you follow the ones whose picks matter most to you.