All scores →
Loading…
Loading…
Loading…

The rise of the girls' game: Title IX and high school basketball

By 4Basketball Staff · · 11 min read

How girls' high school basketball went from restricted rules and thin budgets to a mainstream sport, through six-on-six play, the 1972 Title IX law, landmark scorers and the long fight for equal treatment.

For much of the twentieth century, a girl who wanted to play basketball in an American high school faced a set of obstacles that her brother never met. In many places she could not play at all. In others she played a version of the game with different rules, under a coach who also taught three classes, in a gym she could use only after the boys had finished, on a schedule that ended in February with no real postseason. The idea that she might one day earn a scholarship, a professional contract or a roar from ten thousand fans was close to unthinkable.

The change from that world to the present one is among the largest in the history of American sport, and it happened in a surprisingly short time. A federal law, passed in 1972, set it in motion. A generation of girls, parents, coaches and lawyers pushed it forward. By the end of the century, girls' basketball was one of the most widely played sports in American high schools, and the players it produced were filling college rosters and, from 1997, a professional league. The story is not one of simple triumph, because inequities remain, but it is a story worth understanding in detail.

This article follows the girls' game from its early restrictions through the six-player era, the passage of Title IX, the years of rapid expansion and the continuing arguments over equal treatment. It is a companion to the history of high school basketball, and it goes deeper on the changes that reshaped the sport for half its players.

Early rules and the six-player game

Women's basketball began almost as soon as the game itself. Senda Berenson, who directed physical education at Smith College, adapted Naismith's rules for her students in the early 1890s, producing a version intended to limit roughness and exhaustion. The reasoning reflected the beliefs of the time about what women's bodies could handle, and the adaptations were widely copied. The history is told in more detail in the women's game from Senda Berenson to the WNBA.

One of the most durable of the adaptations divided the court into zones and limited each player to a section of the floor. Over time the most common form was a six-player game, with three forwards who were allowed to shoot and three guards who stayed on the defensive end. For decades this was the girls' game in much of the country. It had its own skills, its own strategies and, in the states that committed to it, its own stars. But it was a separate sport from the one boys played, and it left girls unprepared for the five-player, full-court game used in college and, later, the professional ranks.

The six-player game lasted longest in a few states, most notably Iowa and Oklahoma. Iowa's girls' tournament, run by a separate association for girls, became a major event with large crowds and extensive coverage, long before girls' sports had attention of that kind elsewhere. Its stars were local celebrities. Denise Long of Union-Whitten High School, a forward, scored 111 points in a single game in 1968, a total that became legendary in the state, and an NBA team made headlines with a publicity gesture of drafting her the following year, though the league did not recognize the selection. The Iowa six-player game was eventually replaced by the five-player version in the early 1990s, and Oklahoma followed a few years later.

The six-player tradition is a reminder that "women's basketball" was not always the same game as "men's basketball," and that the transition to a common set of rules was itself a matter of controversy. Many players and fans in those states loved the old game and mourned its end, even as the change brought girls into line with the sport at the next level.

What Title IX did, and did not, say

The law that changed the landscape was Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972, signed in June of that year. Its core sentence is short: no person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any education program or activity receiving federal financial assistance. Nothing in the text mentions athletics. But because nearly every public school, and many private ones, receive federal funds, the law applied to school sports, and the courts and federal agencies interpreted it that way.

It is worth being precise about what the law requires. It does not demand that schools spend identical amounts on boys' and girls' teams, and it does not mandate that every team have the same number of players. It requires that schools provide equal opportunity. Over time, regulators developed a way to evaluate compliance, often described as a three-part test for participation: schools can show that participation opportunities for each sex are substantially proportionate to enrollment, or that they have a history and continuing practice of expanding opportunities for the underrepresented sex, or that they have fully and effectively accommodated the interests and abilities of the underrepresented sex. In addition, schools are expected to treat girls' and boys' programs equitably in areas such as equipment, scheduling, travel, coaching, facilities and publicity.

The law was not self-enforcing. It took years of regulation, lawsuits and political fights to translate the principle into practice. Court decisions in the 1980s narrowed its reach for a time, and Congress responded by restoring its breadth. Schools were slow to change, and in many cases changed only after a complaint. But the law gave girls and their parents a legal tool, and it shifted the burden of justification onto schools that wanted to offer less. A fuller account appears in our article on women's basketball and the 1972 Title IX law.

The numbers that changed

Participation figures show the effect most clearly. In the early 1970s, only a small fraction of girls played interscholastic sports, a number in the low hundreds of thousands nationally, compared to millions of boys. In the decades after Title IX, the girls' number grew many times over, and basketball was one of the sports that led the way. It was cheap to start, needed a gym that schools already had and fit the winter calendar. Girls' basketball became a standard part of the athletic program at nearly every school.

The growth did more than increase the number of players. It changed the quality of play. As more girls played earlier, with better coaching and more competition, the level rose. Skills that had been rare, such as dribbling with both hands under pressure, shooting from distance and finishing through contact, became standard. The full-court five-player game made all of this possible. Young players who grew up in the 1980s and 1990s were far more prepared for the next level than those of a generation earlier, and the college game improved as a result.

The leap in participation also created new needs. Schools had to hire coaches, build or schedule gym time, buy uniforms, arrange transportation and recruit officials. Associations created girls' tournaments, often modeled on the boys', and added classifications and playoffs. The development of the postseason in each state is part of the story told in state championships and classifications.

The seasons fight

One of the less-known battles concerned when girls played. In a number of states, girls' basketball was scheduled in a different season from boys', often in the fall or in a compressed period, so that the gym would be available to the boys in winter. The practical effect was that girls competing in an off-season had less exposure to college recruiters, who watched winter games, and fewer chances to play on travel teams that ran in other seasons. It also meant that a girl who wanted to play basketball and another sport had a harder time doing both.

Lawsuits, based on Title IX and state laws, challenged these arrangements. Courts and associations gradually brought most states into line, aligning the girls' season with the boys'. The move created its own complications. Gym time had to be shared more evenly, which meant earlier games for some teams and later ones for others, and doubleheaders raised questions of which team played in the better time slot. But the alignment helped girls' players gain the recruiting exposure and the postseason prominence that boys had long enjoyed.

The issue illustrates a feature of the whole story: equality is not just a question of whether girls can play, but of when, where, in front of whom and with what support. Each of those details was a separate fight.

Who coaches the girls

A less-discussed consequence of Title IX concerns the sidelines. Before the law, most girls' teams were coached by women, often physical education teachers who ran the program as one more duty and received little or no extra pay. As girls' sports gained status, budgets and stipends, the jobs became more attractive, and men began to take a larger share of them. Researchers who studied the trend found that the proportion of women coaching women's teams fell sharply in the decades after 1972, even as the number of teams rose. The pattern is one of the unintended consequences of the law's success, and it has led to continuing efforts to recruit and keep women coaches, who serve as role models and bring a different view of the player's experience.

The coaching question also connects to the broader supply of adults who work in girls' basketball: officials, athletic trainers, athletic directors and broadcasters. Each of these groups was overwhelmingly male at the start of the post-Title IX era, and each has changed slowly. For a girl who wants a lasting place in the sport, the number of visible ways to stay involved after her playing days is much larger today than it was, but the leadership ranks remain a place where progress has been uneven.

Stars who made the game visible

A sport grows when it produces players who capture attention, and the girls' game had many. Cheryl Miller of Riverside Polytechnic High School in California was perhaps the first to become a national figure. She was a tall, athletic and charismatic player who dominated her era, and in a 1982 game she scored 105 points. She went on to a celebrated career at the University of Southern California and later as a coach and broadcaster. Her profile helped show that a woman could be a star on the court in the same way that men were.

Lisa Leslie, who attended Morningside High School in Inglewood, California, scored 101 points in the first half of a game in 1990, after which her opponent forfeited the second half. Leslie went on to USC, the Olympics and the WNBA, and her story is told in our profile of Lisa Leslie. Her high school scoring display was an indication of how dominant a skilled player could be against competition that had not yet adapted to the new level of the game.

Other players followed. Diana Taurasi, Candace Parker, Tamika Catchings and many more became known to high school fans before they were famous nationally, and their college and professional careers extended the girls' game's reach. The WNBA's founding in 1997 gave the sport a professional destination, and the pipeline from high school to college to the league became more defined. The league's story appears in the history of the WNBA.

Equity today: the unfinished work

Participation in girls' basketball is high, but equal treatment is not always complete. Disputes in schools and districts over facilities, scheduling, coaching pay, travel budgets, uniforms and publicity continue to arise. Girls' teams have sometimes been assigned weaker time slots or smaller gyms, have had fewer resources for promotion and have been offered less support from booster clubs. Sometimes the differences are subtle, such as the way a banner is displayed or the number of game nights televised.

The reasons are partly structural. Boys' basketball has a longer history, a bigger base of fans and booster support, and in many communities, boys' teams generate more revenue. Schools can be reluctant to change a system that works for the established program. Title IX's requirement of equitable treatment is meant to prevent the revenue difference from becoming a justification for unequal support, but enforcement depends on complaints from students and families.

Rules for the girls' game also differ in small ways from the boys', and these reflect history. In high school, girls use a smaller ball than boys, the same size as in women's college and professional basketball, which is explained in the article on the ball. Most other rules are the same. The differences are not about the capacity of the players but about the traditions of the leagues in which the game developed.

The girls' pathway after high school

The girls' game now has a clear path beyond the high school gym. College programs recruit actively, scholarships are available at the highest levels and the women's tournament has become a major event; the story of that development is in women's college basketball. The WNBA offers a professional destination, and international leagues provide opportunities to play overseas. For a girl growing up today, the possibilities are far broader than those available fifty years ago.

Club basketball, which runs in the spring and summer, plays a large role in that pathway, as it does for boys. Families who want to understand how club, school and other routes fit together can read basketball for girls and women: youth, school and club pathways. The structure that supports all of this, from the youth level to the state association, has been built in a half century, and much of it is younger than the parents who now take their daughters to games.

What to take away

The rise of the girls' game reminds us that sports institutions are made, not given. The six-player rules, the separate seasons, the underfunded programs and the thin crowds were choices, and they changed because people, and eventually the law, demanded change. Title IX did not create the talent, but it created the conditions in which the talent could appear.

If you are a fan, a parent or an administrator, the lasting lesson is practical. Equality in sports depends on details: the time of the game, the quality of the gym, the support of the booster club, the seriousness with which the school treats the team. Notice them. And enjoy the result, a sport with a full pipeline from the elementary school to the WNBA. You can follow current teams and results in the high school section of the site.

Search more on this

Keep reading