All scores →
Loading…
Loading…
Loading…

The NBA All-Star Game: how teams are picked and what has changed

By 4Basketball Staff · · 11 min read

How the NBA All-Star Game works: the fan, player and media vote, the coaches' reserves, injury replacements, the captain format, the Elam ending and the long argument over defense and effort.

The NBA All-Star Game is the strangest major event on the basketball calendar. It is a mid-season exhibition with no standings consequence, played by the league's best players who are asked to compete hard but are not asked to risk injury. Fans vote for it with enthusiasm, critics complain about it almost every year, and the league keeps changing it. Few events in sports have been redesigned so often while remaining so recognizably the same.

This article explains how the game works. It covers how the players are selected, what the starters and reserves are, what happens when someone is hurt, how the teams themselves are formed, and how the format has changed over the past decade. It also looks at the history behind the game, the best-known moments, and the argument that has followed it for decades: whether the game is a serious contest or an expensive celebration. If you want to see the stars of the other events that fill the weekend, our guide to the Rising Stars, Slam Dunk and Three-Point contests covers them.

The details of selection and format have changed more than once, so what follows describes the principles and the most important rules, rather than a single season's fine print.

A short history of the game

The first NBA All-Star Game was played in 1951 in Boston, with the East beating the West. Ed Macauley of the Celtics was named the most valuable player, the first of many to win the award. The game was created to promote the league, which was then still a young organization trying to build an audience outside its core cities, and the idea was simple: put the best players from each division on the same floor and let them play.

For decades the structure stayed constant. The East played the West, and the players were chosen by a combination of voting and coaches' decisions. The game grew with the league, and by the 1980s it had become a weekend of events, with the Slam Dunk and Three-Point contests added to the program. The game itself was played in a different city each year, with the league's Board of Governors choosing the host, which gave the event an additional role: a reward for cities with new or renovated arenas, and a showcase for a market's hospitality.

The only season in which the game was not played was 1999, when a labor dispute shortened the season and the league canceled the All-Star festivities. That cancellation shows how much of the event depends on the health of the league's labor relations. When the sides could not agree, even a mid-season exhibition became a casualty.

Moments that made the game famous

Every long-running exhibition accumulates memories. Michael Jordan's performance at the 1988 game in Chicago, in his home arena, is remembered for a 40-point effort and the Most Valuable Player award. In 1992 Magic Johnson, who had retired from the Lakers a few months earlier after announcing that he had HIV, returned to play in the All-Star Game in Orlando. He was voted in by fans, he won the MVP award, and the game ended with the other stars letting him take center stage. Few All-Star moments have carried as much weight.

Bob Pettit and Kobe Bryant share the record for MVP awards in the game, with four each. Pettit, a dominant forward of the 1950s, is profiled in Bob Pettit: career, style and legacy, and Kobe Bryant's four awards came across a long career, as detailed in Kobe Bryant: career, style and legacy. The game's scoring records have also moved upward. Wilt Chamberlain's 42 points in 1962 stood for decades. Anthony Davis scored 52 in 2017 in New Orleans, and Jayson Tatum scored 55 in 2023 in Salt Lake City. Those records say more about the relaxed defense of the game than about the quality of the shooters, a point we return to below.

Who gets picked: starters and reserves

An All-Star team is made of twelve players per conference, divided into starters and reserves. Five players start for each side. The other seven come off the bench.

The starters

For many years, fans alone chose the starters. Ballots were distributed at arenas and, later, online, and the game became a popularity contest, which caused the occasional embarrassment when a well-liked veteran who was no longer playing at a high level won a starting spot over a more deserving rival. In 2017 the league changed the process to give the vote a more balanced shape. Starters are now chosen by a combination of three groups: the fans, who carry half the weight, and current players and a panel of media members, who each carry a quarter. Each group ranks the candidates, and the rankings are combined into a weighted score.

The reasoning is straightforward. Fans have the numbers, but players know who is truly good, and the media see most of the games. A blended vote keeps the fan voice dominant while correcting for the cases in which a famous name outshines a stronger season. The ballot itself has also changed. For years it was divided into guards, forwards and a center. In 2013 the league changed it to guards and frontcourt players, a recognition that the center position was shrinking and that many of the best big men could play several roles. The change followed a broader movement in the game, discussed in positionless basketball.

The reserves

Reserves are chosen by the head coaches of the league. Each coach votes for seven players from his own conference, including guards, frontcourt players and wild cards, and cannot vote for his own players. The wild cards allow coaches to pick the best remaining players without regard to position. The top vote-getters at each position group, plus the best of the wild cards, fill the seven reserve places.

This process puts the choice in the hands of the people who plan against the players. Coaches have the strongest motive to be accurate, since they see these players night after night and design game plans to stop them. They also know who is truly effective rather than merely flashy. The process is not flawless, and every year there are debates about who was left out, but it tends to produce a more deserving group than a fan vote on its own.

Injury replacements

Injuries are a regular feature of the process. When a selected player cannot take part, the league's commissioner chooses a replacement. The commissioner names the replacement from the same conference, and the player is treated as an All-Star for that year, which carries real weight for contracts, legacies and sometimes incentive clauses written into contracts. A player who has been injured may still be listed as an All-Star and attend the festivities, although he does not play.

The fact that an All-Star selection can trigger bonuses and shape a player's legacy also gives it an importance beyond the exhibition. The Hall of Fame, which we discuss in the Hall of Fame: how players, coaches and contributors get in, often considers All-Star appearances as part of a player's case.

How the teams themselves are formed

For most of the game's history, there was no need to explain how the teams were formed: the East played the West, and the rosters were the All-Stars from those conferences. But in 2018 the league introduced a new format, abandoning the East-West divide.

The captain format

In the new system, the top vote-getter in each conference became a captain. The captains then chose their teams from the pool of All-Stars, in an order that began with the starters and continued with the reserves. The result was two teams, named after the captains, that mixed players from both conferences. In the first year, LeBron James and Stephen Curry were the captains, and Team LeBron won. The change turned the roster selection into entertainment: fans could follow who was picked and who was left to the end, and the draft itself became a talking point.

The captain format had a logic. It created games that were less lopsided than a conference matchup, since the captains could balance the rosters, and it added drama to a game that otherwise lacked stakes. It also gave players a personal incentive to win, since they were playing for the captain who had chosen them.

The league went back to East versus West in 2024, after several years of the captain format. The change reflected the view that fans found the conference matchup more traditional and that the draft had run its course. Since then the league has continued to experiment, and it has tried tournament-style formats with multiple teams, a sign that the design of the game remains unsettled. Because the format is likely to change again, any description of a specific year's design is a snapshot.

The Elam Ending

In 2020 the league introduced a new way of ending the game. In the fourth quarter, the game clock was turned off and a target score was set: the leading team's score after three quarters plus 24 points. The first team to reach the target won the game. The number 24 honored Kobe Bryant, who had died earlier that year, and the MVP trophy was renamed for him. The idea behind the ending was borrowed from a proposal by a university professor, Nick Elam, and is known as the Elam Ending.

The effect was immediate. Instead of a casual final quarter in which both teams traded shots without urgency, the last minutes featured defensive stops, fouling and real competitiveness, because each possession counted toward a fixed target. The 2020 game in Chicago ended with Team LeBron beating Team Giannis by two points, and the closing minutes were among the most intense in the history of the exhibition. The ending has become a fixture, and it is an example of how an experiment can address the game's central problem.

The changes at a glance

The sequence of changes is easier to follow in one place. The table lists the main turning points described above, with the reason each one is usually given.

Year Change Why it mattered
1951 First game, East against West Promoted a young league
1999 Game not played Labor dispute cut the season
2013 Ballot moved to guards and frontcourt Reflected the decline of the traditional center
2017 Starters chosen by fans, players and media Balanced the fan vote with expert opinion
2018 Captains pick the teams Replaced East-West with a draft
2020 Elam Ending and Kobe Bryant tribute Made the final quarter competitive
2024 Return to East versus West Restored the traditional matchup

Read down the middle column and a pattern appears. Almost every change was made for the same reason: the league wanted the game to look and feel like a contest without asking the players to take risks that would not make sense in February. The ballot changes were about who deserves to be on the floor, while the format changes were about what the players do once they are there. That is a useful distinction for anyone judging whether a new idea will work. A change to the selection process affects the roster and the headlines, but a change to the scoring or the clock affects the behavior of the players, which is the thing fans complain about.

The problem of defense

Anyone who has watched an All-Star Game knows the central complaint: nobody defends. Players are paid to avoid injury during the long season, and the game takes place in the middle of it. The best shooters, passers and dunkers are on the floor together, and the usual restraints are lifted. The result is a game that produces enormous scores and little resistance.

The numbers confirm the impression. In the last decade, teams in the game have scored in the 150s and beyond, and the 2024 edition produced the highest scores in the history of the exhibition, with the East scoring above 200. Those totals come from the absence of a team defense, not from superior shooting. A defender who gives a star an open lane or a clear three-point shot is following an unspoken agreement.

It is worth understanding that agreement. Nobody wants to be the player who injures a star in an exhibition, and no player wants to be embarrassed by a dunk. So the sensible approach is to leave the defense to the competitors who want to take it seriously. The Elam Ending is the league's attempt to change that incentive, and it has helped in the final quarter, but the first three quarters remain relaxed.

A useful way to think about it is that the All-Star Game is a different sport from the regular season. It is closer to a showcase of skill than to a contest of systems, and the best way to enjoy it is to watch individual players do things that a competitive game would not allow. Whether that is a satisfying product is a matter of taste. The league has chosen to defend the game by changing its structure rather than abandoning it.

The weekend around the game

The game does not stand alone. It is the centerpiece of a weekend that has its own events. On Friday, the Rising Stars game features young players. On Saturday night, the Three-Point Contest, the Slam Dunk Contest and a skills event give the event its flavor. The Sunday game then caps the weekend. For the city that hosts, the weekend is a major economic event, with fans, media, sponsors and visiting executives coming to town.

The weekend also offers an unusual window into the league's culture. Players who rarely have time to relax gather in one place, and the league uses the time to announce business initiatives and to honor its history, including the recognition of the league's best players on anniversary teams, such as the NBA's 75th anniversary team. It is a rare chance to see the league as a community, not just a competition.

The women's game has its own tradition. The WNBA stages an All-Star Game of its own, and the formats there have also been redesigned more than once, including matchups against national teams. You can follow the league through WNBA coverage.

What to take away

The NBA All-Star Game is chosen by a mix of fans, players and media for the starters and by the coaches for the reserves, with the commissioner filling vacancies when someone is injured. The format has moved from East versus West to the captain draft and back, with an Elam Ending added in 2020 to make the closing minutes competitive. The game's scoring records have risen, and the central complaint is about defense.

If you want to enjoy it, watch it as a showcase, not a playoff. Look for the passes, the shots and the combinations of players who rarely share a floor. For the rest of the season, the real competition is on the scores page and in the standings, where every game counts.

Search more on this

Keep reading

Overtime: how extra periods work in each league

When regulation ends level, basketball keeps playing. Here is how overtime works in the NBA, WNBA, college, FIBA and high school games, why it feels different, and the famous extra-period games that defined it.

4Basketball Staff · May 8, 2026 · 11 min read