All scores →
Loading…
Loading…
Loading…

Positionless basketball: do the five positions still matter?

By 4Basketball Staff · · 11 min read

Positionless basketball says labels no longer matter. This article traces where the five positions came from, how the game outgrew them and which jobs on the floor still have to be filled.

Ask a longtime fan to explain basketball to a newcomer and the explanation usually starts with the five positions: a point guard who runs the offense, a shooting guard who scores, a small forward who does a bit of everything, a power forward who rebounds and a center who protects the basket. It is a tidy picture, and for much of the sport's history it described real differences in how players were built and used. Then, over the last few decades, the picture began to blur. Centers started shooting threes. Forwards started running the offense. Guards started grabbing rebounds and defending bigger players. Commentators began to use a new word: positionless.

The word is both useful and misleading. It captures something true, that the boundaries between roles have become porous and that the most valuable players are the ones who can do several jobs. But it can also suggest that the jobs themselves have disappeared, that five players can stand on the floor and each do everything. That is not what happens. Every lineup still has to handle the ball, shoot, space the floor, defend the rim, rebound, screen and pass. What has changed is that those tasks are no longer attached to fixed labels.

This article looks at where the five positions came from, what they were meant to describe, how the game outgrew them, and what remains true underneath the change. The answer to the title question is a qualified yes. The labels matter less than they used to. The functions matter as much as ever.

Where the five positions came from

The five-position scheme grew out of the way early basketball was organized and the way players were built. In the first decades of the sport, teams used two guards, two forwards and a center, a simple division of labor that mirrored the geometry of the court. Guards brought the ball up the floor and shot from outside. Forwards played along the baseline and the wings. The center, usually the tallest player, stayed near the basket, took the jump ball in the early rules, and scored from close range.

Over time, the two-guard, two-forward, one-center structure was refined into five labels, with the guards split into a point guard and a shooting guard and the forwards into a small forward and a power forward. A fuller description of what each position traditionally did appears in Basketball positions explained: point guard to center. The shorthand of numbers, one through five, became common in coaching language because it allowed a coach to call a play by position: the "one" brings the ball up, the "five" sets a screen.

These labels were useful for reasons beyond tradition. Players really were different. A 6-foot-10 player in the 1950s or 1960s was rare, and when he was available, he went to the basket, because nobody else could do what he did. A small, quick player with good handles was the ball handler, because the alternatives could not dribble well. The positions were an efficient way to describe a division of labor that came from physical reality, and they remained a good description for decades.

The first cracks

Even in the era of strict positions, great players challenged them. Oscar Robertson, a big guard, played the point with the height and strength of a forward and posted up smaller defenders. Elgin Baylor, a forward, rebounded and handled the ball in a way that previewed later generations. Wilt Chamberlain, a center, led the league in assists in the late 1960s, a feat that suggested what a big man could do if asked. These players were exceptions, but they showed that the labels described habits rather than limits.

The decisive demonstration came with Magic Johnson, a 6-foot-9 point guard who could see the floor over most defenders and run an offense with creativity and flair. In Game 6 of the 1980 NBA Finals, with Kareem Abdul-Jabbar injured, Johnson, then a rookie, started at center for the Los Angeles Lakers and produced a performance that remains one of the most celebrated in Finals history, finishing with 42 points, 15 rebounds and 7 assists in a series-clinching win over the Philadelphia 76ers. That night proved a point that coaches had long suspected: if the person is good enough, the label is a convenience. The longer story of his career is in Magic Johnson: career, style and legacy.

Scottie Pippen is another example. As the second star of the Chicago Bulls, he handled the ball, initiated the offense and guarded the opponent's best player, whether guard or forward. The role became known as the "point forward," a concept covered in Playing through a point guard versus a point forward. The triangle offense, which Pippen thrived in, helped by assigning roles by spots on the floor rather than by position, so a forward could run the offense from the wing, and a center could pass from the post. See The triangle offense: spacing, reads and why it faded for how that system worked.

What really broke the labels: the three-point shot and the switch

If a few great players bent the rules, the three-point shot broke them. As teams began to value spacing, they needed more players on the floor who could shoot from long range. A center who could not shoot was now a liability in the half court, because his defender could stay near the basket and clog the lane. A forward who could shoot and handle the ball became a premium asset. The result was a steady shift of skills across the traditional boundaries: guards got taller and bigger, forwards got more skilled, and centers learned to pass, dribble and shoot.

At the same time, defenses changed. Teams began to switch screens, which meant that a lineup of five players with similar skill sets was an advantage, since any player could defend any other. A defender who can guard a guard on one possession and a center on the next is worth more than a specialist in a switching scheme. This is the logic described in Switch-everything defense and its weakness: mismatches. It encouraged coaches to look for versatile players at every spot and to play them together.

The Golden State Warriors of the mid-2010s made the point visible. With Draymond Green at center in some lineups, surrounded by shooters and passers, they had five players who could handle the ball, make decisions and defend multiple positions, and the result was a team that was difficult to match up against. Their title run is part of the story in The 2010s: the Warriors, LeBron and the three-point revolution. Around the league, coaches began experimenting with small lineups, with "five-out" structures in which every player could shoot from the perimeter, and with big men whose primary skill was passing. The latter idea reached its fullest form in centers who became the hub of their team's offense and won Most Valuable Player awards without playing like traditional centers.

What "positionless" really means

At this point it helps to define the term carefully, because it is used in at least three ways.

  1. Positionless players. A player who can do many things, such as handle the ball, pass, shoot, rebound and defend several types of opponent, and who does not fit neatly into one label.
  2. Positionless lineups. Groupings of five players, each of whom can perform several roles, so that the lineup is flexible and difficult to attack.
  3. Positionless offense. Systems in which the ball handler is whoever has the ball, and the screener, spacer and cutter roles rotate from possession to possession.

The first is a description of talent. The second is a decision by a coach. The third is a structure. They are related but not identical, and a team can have one without the others. A team with a single versatile big man still has a roster full of specialists, and a team that plays a positionless offense still needs players who can execute it.

The most useful way to think about the idea is as a change in what a coach is looking for. A traditional coach asked, "Who is my point guard? Who is my center?" A modern coach is more likely to ask, "Who can handle the ball? Who can protect the rim? Who can space the floor? Who can rebound? Who can guard the other team's best scorer?" Those questions have answers that may be found in different players from lineup to lineup. The functions are the stable thing. The labels are the changeable one.

The functions that still need to be filled

If you strip away the labels, a basketball team still needs to solve a set of problems on every possession.

Function Offensive version Defensive version
Ball handling and decision making Start the offense, read the defense Pressure the ball, stay in front
Shooting and spacing Stretch the defense so others can attack Close out, contest
Rim protection Not applicable Deter and alter shots at the basket
Rebounding Win second chances End possessions
Screening and rolling Create separation Fight through or switch
Passing Connect the pieces Anticipate and intercept

Any lineup that lacks one of these will struggle. A team of five good shooters with no rim protection will give up points inside. A team of five rim protectors with no spacing will have trouble scoring. A team with no one who can create off the dribble may bog down when the shot clock runs low. Positionless basketball does not erase these needs. It lets teams meet them with players whose skills overlap, so that the loss of a specialist does not break the lineup.

This is where the common misunderstanding lives. The phrase "positionless" is sometimes taken to mean that skills are interchangeable. They are not. Rim protection is a particular craft, as described in Rim protection: verticality, timing and the shot-blocker's craft, and not every player can do it. Ball handling under pressure is another distinct craft. A lineup that includes several players who can do several things is more flexible than one that does not, but it still has to include the right things. The topic of balance is discussed in Lineup construction: balancing shooting, rim protection and playmaking.

Where positions still matter

There are several places where the five labels continue to carry real weight.

Size and physical constraints. The court has not changed. Rebounding is still easier for taller, stronger players, and rim protection still favors length. A lineup of five 6-foot-5 players can switch everything, but it will give up rebounds and shots at the basket. Most teams still want at least one player with the height and strength to protect the rim, and the market still rewards the rare player who can do that and also pass and shoot.

Youth development. Young players benefit from learning the traditional roles. A child who is tall at twelve and told to play only on the perimeter may miss the chance to learn post footwork, and a child who is small and told to play only in the paint may miss ball handling. Many coaches, even those who admire positionless play at the professional level, teach fundamentals by position at younger ages, then widen the roles as skills develop. The sound approach is to teach all of the skills to all of the players when possible and to avoid locking children into a label before their bodies are finished growing. That idea is developed in Coaching youth basketball: what to teach at each age.

Defensive assignments. Even in a switching scheme, matchups matter. Coaches decide who guards the opponent's best scorer, who covers the best rebounder and who handles the pick-and-roll ball handler. These assignments often follow size and quickness, which correlate with the old positions.

Fantasy and statistics. Fantasy leagues and databases still sort players by position, because those labels carry information about the statistics a player is likely to produce. As players become more versatile, the categories have loosened, but they have not gone away. The rules for eligibility are explained in Fantasy basketball positions and eligibility rules.

Communication. Coaches and players still use position language because it is compact. Saying "the five sets the screen" or "the two is in the corner" conveys a lot in a few words.

A way of seeing it

Here is a perspective that may be useful. The old positions were really a bundle of skills that tended to appear in the same body. A tall person tended to rebound and protect the rim, so we called him a center. A small person tended to handle the ball and pass, so we called him a point guard. The label was a convenient shortcut for a bundle.

What the modern game did was unbundle the skills. Today it is possible to find a tall player who also handles and passes, and a small player who also defends and rebounds. When the bundles are broken apart, the labels stop being useful predictors, and teams assemble lineups from individual skills. But the skills themselves are the same ones that the old positions were describing. In that sense, positionless basketball does not abolish the positions. It reveals what they were made of.

This view also explains why some teams succeed with traditional structures and others with unconventional ones. The question is never whether a lineup has the right labels. It is whether it has all the skills the game demands, and whether the skills fit together. A traditional lineup that covers every function is fine. An unconventional lineup that leaves a gap is not. Labels are a means, not an end.

What to take away

The five positions are best understood as a historical shorthand for a bundle of skills that used to come together. The modern game, driven by the three-point shot, the pick and roll and the rise of switching defenses, has taken the bundle apart, and the best players now do jobs that once belonged to different labels. But the jobs remain: someone must handle, space, protect, rebound, screen and pass. A lineup that fills those jobs well will win whatever the roster sheet says.

For a fan, the practical lesson is to watch functions rather than labels. When a team is struggling, ask which job is going undone. When a team is excelling, look at which players are doing more than one thing. And when someone tells you that positions are dead, remember that a center still has to guard the rim, a point guard still has to run the offense, and the five labels, for all their flaws, remain a good starting point for understanding what the game asks of five people at once.

Search more on this

Keep reading