All scores →
Loading…
Loading…
Loading…

Shopping for lines: why having several accounts matters

By 4Basketball Staff · · 12 min read

Different sportsbooks post slightly different prices on the same game. Here is the arithmetic of line shopping, why it is the oldest edge in the business, and the cautions that come with it.

This article explains how betting markets work. It is not advice and not an encouragement to bet. Sports betting is legal only in some places and only for adults, usually 21 and over in the United States. Over time the odds favor the house. If gambling is a problem for you or someone you know, call 1-800-GAMBLER, the National Problem Gambling Helpline in the United States.

Two shops on the same street sell the same loaf of bread at different prices, and nobody is surprised. Sportsbooks are shops too, and the product they sell, a price on the outcome of a basketball game, is no more standardized than bread. One book may list a team at -6.5. Another lists the same team at -6. A third has -6.5 but charges -115 on it where the first charges -110. The game is identical. The price is not.

Those gaps are small, and that is exactly why they matter. Nobody gets rich on half a point once. But a bettor who pays the better price on every wager, year after year, keeps a little more of every dollar than a bettor who takes whatever number is nearest. This is called line shopping, and it is one of the few things in betting that is purely a matter of arithmetic rather than opinion. It does not require a view about who will win. It only requires comparing prices.

This article explains why prices differ between books, how to measure the difference in terms that matter, why the practice leads people toward holding more than one account, and what the practical and personal downsides are. If you have read our guides to how to read odds and the vig and the hold, this is where those two ideas meet.

Why the same game has different prices

A sportsbook is a business managing risk, and no two businesses manage it identically. Several things push their numbers apart.

Different models and different judgment. Every book starts from some estimate of how a game should go. They buy data from overlapping sources and employ their own traders, but the final number reflects a house view, and house views differ by a fraction of a point.

Different customers. A book whose clientele leans toward betting favorites and overs will see its exposure pile up on one side and may shade its numbers accordingly. A book with a very different customer base will shade differently. The same game can therefore look slightly cheaper on one side at one book.

Different timing. News arrives at different moments for different traders. When a star's availability changes, one book moves its number within minutes and another a little later. For a short window the market is inconsistent, and the price you see depends on which book you open. Our article on injuries and the market covers why those windows are shorter than they used to be.

Different margins. Each book decides how much to charge for taking a bet. The standard price on a spread is -110 on both sides, which is the familiar "pay 110 to win 100." Some books post -105 or -108 on certain games to attract volume, and some charge -115 or more on markets where they are less eager. The charge is built into the price, which is why two books can post the same spread and still offer different value.

Different positions. A book that has already taken a lot of money on one side may move the number to discourage more of it, even if it believes the number was fine. A competitor with a balanced book sees no reason to move.

None of this means any book is wrong in a way you can exploit consistently. It means the market is a collection of slightly different prices, and the spread between the best and the worst is the thing line shopping captures. Our piece on line movement explains how those numbers drift in the days before tip-off, and the differences between books tend to be widest right after a move begins.

What a better price is worth

Start with the most common price in basketball, the spread bet at -110. You risk 110 to win 100. If you break even over a long run, you must win a share of bets that covers the extra 10 you pay when you lose. The break-even rate is 110 divided by 210, which is 52.38 percent. Anything less and you lose money over time, which is how the book makes its living.

Now suppose a different book offers the same spread at -105. The break-even rate there is 105 divided by 205, which is 51.22 percent. The gap is 1.16 percentage points, and that gap is entirely a gift of the price. If your underlying win rate on a type of bet is, say, exactly 52 percent, you lose money at -110 and make a small profit at -105. The skill is the same. The result is not.

Another way to see it is as a cost. At -110, the margin you pay on a bet that is truly fifty-fifty is about 4.5 percent of the stake. At -105 it is about 2.4 percent. Cutting the cost in half is a larger improvement than most bettors will ever make through better analysis. If this is new to you, our explanation of expected value lays out the logic: the price is part of the bet, and a better price improves expected value even when your view of the game has not changed.

The half point

The other form of price difference is the number itself. If one book has a team at -6.5 and another has the same team at -6, the second is the better price for anyone backing the favorite, because the team can win by exactly six and still cover only at the second book. For anyone backing the underdog, the first book is better: at +6.5, a six-point loss covers there but would push at +6.

How much is a half point worth? It depends on how often games end on that exact margin. In basketball, final margins are spread across a wide range, because scoring comes in ones, twos and threes and a game has well over a hundred points in it. If you model NBA margins with a standard deviation of roughly twelve points, a common approximation, then somewhere near the middle of the range any single margin comes up in a bit under three percent of games. That is the rough value of moving a spread by a half point in either direction: a gain or loss on the order of a percentage point or two in break-even terms, depending on where the number sits.

That is smaller than the corresponding figure in football, where scores cluster on a few margins such as three and seven, and it is one reason basketball bettors talk less about "key numbers." But a percentage point or so is the same order of magnitude as the whole difference between -110 and -105 pricing. The two sources of edge, the number and the juice, can add up or cancel out, which is why a careful shopper compares both.

A worked example

Suppose three books show the following prices on the same game, with the home team as the favorite.

Book Favorite Underdog
A -6.5 at -110 +6.5 at -110
B -6 at -110 +6 at -110
C -6.5 at -105 +6.5 at -115

A bettor who wants the favorite would prefer B on the number or C on the price. A bettor who wants the underdog would prefer A over B on the number, because +6.5 beats +6, and would avoid C because of the -115. Nobody knows ahead of time which side will be right. What the table shows is that the best price depends on which side you are on, and that having access to only one of these books means accepting whichever line it happens to post.

Why that leads to several accounts

The logic is straightforward. To buy the best available price, you need to be able to place a bet at whichever book is offering it. One account gives you one price. Three accounts give you three prices to compare. In a market where the differences are small and persistent, access is the whole game.

In the United States this is possible because betting is licensed state by state. In a state that permits it, several licensed operators compete, and a customer can open an account with more than one. Each account is separate: it has its own balance, its own deposits and withdrawals, and its own terms. The same applies in other countries that license multiple operators.

Some practical points follow, and they matter more than the strategy.

  • Every account must be in your own name. Operators verify identity and age, and an account opened for someone else, or shared, breaks the terms and the law.
  • You must be where betting is legal when you place the bet. Licensed operators use location checks, and a bet is only valid in a place where that operator is licensed.
  • One person, one account per operator. Opening duplicates with the same book to collect a sign-up offer twice is against the terms and is exactly the kind of behavior operators watch for.
  • Money sits in several places. You have to track balances in more than one location, and moving money costs time even when it costs no fees.

For people who prefer not to hold many accounts, comparison tools exist that show prices from several books on one screen. Our own odds page shows book-by-book prices for information only, and the numbers there are a snapshot from a data feed refreshed on a schedule, not a live price. Treat them as a guide to the market, never as a quote you can rely on at the moment you bet. The data sources page explains where the figures come from.

The honest limits of line shopping

It would be dishonest to present line shopping as a cure for a negative expected return, so here are the limits.

It only reduces a cost. If you bet at average prices and lose money over time, line shopping makes the losses slower. It does not turn a losing approach into a winning one. A bettor with no genuine edge over the market still loses over a long run, only less quickly than one who pays more.

It can encourage the wrong behavior. Having five accounts means five logins, five apps, five sets of notifications and five sets of promotions competing for your attention. Each is designed to bring you back. A strategy meant to lower your costs can quietly raise the amount you wager.

The best price is often the worst-limited. A book posting a price that differs from the rest of the market is often posting it only for small stakes. The maximum bet at that price may be modest, and it can drop quickly if the book receives a lot of action. Our article on sportsbook limits, boosts and promotions explains how limits work and why they differ by customer.

Stale prices disappear. By the time you notice a better number, it may have gone. Market-making books update fast. A price that looked clearly better two minutes ago can be gone when you try to place the bet, and many apps will reject or reprice a wager if the line moves while you are confirming it.

Books respond to winners. An operator is entitled to limit or close accounts, within its terms and the law. Those who consistently win may find their maximum stakes cut. This is covered at more length in the limits article, and it is a reminder that the business is not designed around customers who beat it.

Shopping by market, not just by game

Spreads and moneylines are the easiest places to compare, but the same principle applies across every type of wager.

  • Moneylines differ in both directions. A favorite at -240 on one book and -250 on another is a ten-cent difference in the price you pay to win 100. Underdog prices, such as +200 against +210, matter more in percentage terms because the payout is larger. Our guide to moneylines and implied probability shows how to convert any pair of prices to a probability so you can compare them on the same scale.
  • Totals can differ by a point or more between books, especially when injury news is fresh. A total of 224.5 at one book and 225 at another is a half-point gap, and the price attached to each side may differ as well. See our explanation of totals.
  • Player props show the widest gaps of all. A book may list a player's points line at 24.5 where another lists 25.5. Props are less heavily traded, so books disagree more and correct more slowly. The same wider gaps are also a sign of more uncertainty, and props usually carry higher margins and lower limits. Our guide to player props goes through how they are priced.
  • Futures such as championship odds can vary a lot, because the margin built into long-dated markets is larger and the market is less liquid. See futures bets for more.

A useful habit when comparing is to look at the price and the number together, and to convert both to probability so the comparison is fair. A half point better on the number at a worse price is not automatically an improvement.

Promotions are not prices

New customers are often offered bonuses: a deposit match, a bonus bet, an enhanced-odds boost. These look like a price improvement, and some of them are, but they come with conditions that change their value. Bonus bets typically pay only the winnings, not the stake. A matched deposit may need to be wagered several times before it can be withdrawn. Boosts are sometimes available only on a limited stake or only on certain markets.

The point to carry over to line shopping is this: always read the terms. A promotion can nudge a decision about where to open an account, but the day-to-day value of an account is the quality of its prices, and sign-up offers are a one-time event. Anyone choosing a book mainly for its bonus should understand what they would have to bet to unlock it, and whether they would have placed those bets otherwise. The responsible approach is to treat a bonus as a minor extra at best, never as a reason to wager more than you planned.

Keeping control

Because line shopping rewards small, steady, disciplined behavior, it fits poorly with the way many people actually bet, which is emotionally and quickly. Several habits keep the practice honest.

  1. Set a budget before you open any account. Decide how much you are willing to lose for entertainment, treat it as gone, and split it across accounts rather than adding to it.
  2. Use the deposit limits and time-out tools. Licensed operators in most jurisdictions offer them. Setting a limit at each one caps your total, not just a single account's.
  3. Keep a simple record. A list of every wager, the price you took and the best price available at the time shows whether shopping is changing your results or only your sense of control.
  4. Do not chase. A loss at one book is not a reason to place a larger bet at another. See our article on bankroll management for a framework for staying in control, and on responsible gambling for the signs that betting has stopped being a hobby.
  5. Close what you do not use. An account you rarely open is a risk with no benefit.

What to take away

Line shopping is the plainest idea in betting: the same product is sold at different prices, and paying less is better than paying more. The arithmetic is real. A move from -110 to -105 lowers the break-even rate by more than a full percentage point, and a half point on the spread can matter about as much. Over thousands of bets those differences add up.

But the idea has a ceiling. It reduces what you pay; it does not create an edge. It requires more than one account, and more than one account means more temptation, more money to track and more offers designed to pull you back. If you ever find that shopping for lines is turning into betting more often or for more money than you intended, that is a sign to stop and step back, not to open another account. Used with a fixed budget and a clear head, comparing prices is a sensible habit. Used as a reason to keep playing, it is not.

Sports betting is legal only in some places and only for adults. Help lines vary by country; in the United States, the National Problem Gambling Helpline is 1-800-GAMBLER.

Search more on this

Keep reading