Gambling scandals in basketball: Black Sox-style cases and point shaving
From the 1951 college fixes to the Boston College case and the Tim Donaghy affair, this is a history of basketball gambling scandals, how point shaving works, and how the sport tries to protect itself.
This article is a history of gambling scandals in basketball. It is not advice and not an encouragement to bet. Sports betting is legal only in some places and only for adults, usually 21 and over in the United States. Over time the odds favor the house. If gambling is a problem for you or someone you know, call 1-800-GAMBLER, the National Problem Gambling Helpline in the United States.
In 1919, eight members of the Chicago White Sox were accused of conspiring with gamblers to lose the World Series to the Cincinnati Reds. The case became known as the Black Sox scandal, and it is the standard against which every other sports fixing story is measured. It taught the American public something that has never quite worn off: that the game you are watching might not be a contest at all, and that someone may be making money from the result in a way you cannot see.
Basketball has had its own Black Sox moments, and a good many smaller ones. They differ from the baseball story in an important way. In baseball, the 1919 plot was about losing a series. In basketball, the most common form of corruption has been subtler and, for the participants, easier to rationalize: not losing the game, but changing the margin. The tool that made this possible is the point spread, the handicap that decides which side of a bet wins. When a bet depends on the margin, a team can win the game and still lose the bet, and a player who helps that happen can tell himself he did nothing wrong.
This article walks through the main cases, from the college scandals of the early 1950s to the 2007 case of an NBA referee. It explains how point shaving works and why basketball is particularly vulnerable, what the scandals changed, and how the sport tries to protect itself now. It sticks to the well-documented facts and leaves out details that are disputed or uncertain. It also connects to the broader story of betting law, which we cover in our history of legal sports betting in the United States.
Three ways a game can be corrupted
The word "fix" gets used loosely, so it helps to separate the types.
Game fixing. A player, coach or official works to make a team lose, or to decide the winner. This is the 1919 pattern.
Point shaving. A player or players try to keep the margin within a range, so that a favored team wins by less than the spread. The team usually still wins. The gamblers who know about the arrangement bet on the underdog to cover. For the player, the appeal is that he is not losing, and for the gamblers, the payoff is reliable.
Insider information and manipulation of smaller outcomes. An official, player or staff member passes along information the market does not have, or influences a particular statistic or an in-game event. In the modern era, with bets available on individual players' numbers, this category has grown in importance.
All three rely on the same underlying fact: a bettor with knowledge the market lacks has a large advantage, and criminals have always been willing to pay for it.
Why basketball is vulnerable
Several features of the sport help explain why it has been a target.
Few people matter a great deal. A basketball team has five players on the floor, and one of them can account for a large share of its scoring, rebounds or ball handling. Compare a baseball pitcher, who is just one of nine and cannot easily control a whole game, or a football lineman, whose errors are hard to isolate. A single basketball player has many opportunities to affect the outcome through small choices.
The margin is easy to nudge. Basketball is a high-scoring game. A missed defensive rotation, a turnover, a lazy closeout or a missed free throw late in a game can shift the margin by a few points without anyone noticing. Almost any sequence can be explained as a mistake. That makes the point spread especially open to abuse, and it makes the behavior hard to prove. Our article on point spreads explains how the handicap works.
College players are especially exposed. Amateurs do not earn salaries, and in earlier decades they were often under financial pressure while their games drew large audiences and heavy betting. That combination of attention and need is what gamblers look for.
Officials have large influence. A referee calls fouls, and the whistle can change possessions, free throws and the flow of a game. A referee with inside knowledge of betting lines could, in theory, steer a game by a small amount, and a small amount is all that matters when a bet is decided by half a point.
The college scandals of 1951
The first big basketball scandal broke in January 1951. A center at Manhattan College, Junius Kellogg, told authorities that he had been offered a bribe to shave points. His report led to arrests, and investigators in New York uncovered a network that had been paying players at several colleges.
The case reached some of the most prominent programs. City College of New York, which had won both the National Invitation Tournament and the NCAA tournament in 1950, was among the schools involved. Players from Long Island University, Manhattan and New York University were implicated, along with players at Bradley, Toledo and the University of Kentucky. A gambler named Salvatore Sollazzo was at the center of the plot. Roughly thirty players across several colleges were drawn in, and some were convicted or received suspended sentences.
The consequences were broad.
- Programs were punished or suspended. Long Island University dropped basketball for several seasons. Kentucky, one of the sport's powers, had its 1952-53 season canceled by the NCAA.
- The game moved away from Madison Square Garden. Doubleheaders in the Garden had been a major draw and a place where bets were easy to arrange. In the wake of the scandal, many schools shifted their big games to campuses, and the intercity college doubleheader lost its prominence.
- Public trust took a hit. College basketball had been growing quickly as a rival to the pro game. The scandals dented that reputation and made the NCAA more watchful.
It also revealed the pattern that has repeated many times since: a gambler approaches a player, perhaps through a friend or an intermediary, begins with a small request, and then makes it hard to say no.
Jack Molinas and the early NBA
The scandals did not stay in college. Jack Molinas, a star at Columbia, was drafted by the Fort Wayne Pistons and played for them in the early 1953-54 season. In 1954, the NBA suspended him for life for betting on games, including those of his own team. He was out of the league.
Molinas did not leave the betting world. According to the record of later prosecutions, he organized a fixing operation in the late 1950s and early 1960s that involved players at dozens of colleges across the country. When the scheme was exposed in 1961, investigators identified many players, and the fallout touched a number of programs. Molinas was convicted and served prison time.
One of the people caught in the aftermath was Connie Hawkins, a brilliant player at the University of Iowa who had never played a game for the school, and who was named in connection with the investigation as a student who had spoken to gamblers. He was never charged, and by later accounts he had not shaved points. But the NBA barred him from joining the league. Hawkins played for the Harlem Globetrotters and then in the American Basketball Association, where he was the league's Most Valuable Player in its first season, 1967-68. He later sued the NBA, which settled in 1969, and he played in the NBA for several seasons and was inducted into the Hall of Fame. His story is a reminder that scandals do collateral damage: a young player who was guilty of nothing worse than naivety lost years of his career. Our article on the ABA tells more about the league that gave him a place to play.
Boston College, 1978-79
The next major case involved Boston College in the 1978-79 season. A gambler named Henry Hill, a figure in organized crime who later became famous through the book and film that were based on his life, was involved in a scheme to pay players to ensure the team did not cover the spread in some games. One of the players, Rick Kuhn, was convicted in federal court for his role. The case was notable because it tied organized crime directly to college basketball, and because it showed that the pattern of point shaving, rather than outright losing, remained the preferred method.
Tulane, Arizona State and the later cases
The cases kept coming in later decades, each with its own details and its own aftermath.
- Tulane, 1985. An investigation into point shaving led to charges against several players. One of them, John "Hot Rod" Williams, was tried and acquitted, and he went on to a long NBA career. Other players were convicted or pleaded guilty, and the university shut down its basketball program for several seasons.
- Arizona State, 1994. Players were found to have been paid by gamblers to shave points in games during the 1993-94 season, and the case led to prosecutions.
- Northwestern, 1998. Players at Northwestern were charged with shaving points, and some pleaded guilty. The case was especially striking because it involved a university with high academic standards, a reminder that the pressure can reach any program.
- Other cases in the 2000s. Occasional cases involving college players and officials continued to surface.
In 2006, an economist named Justin Wolfers published a study in the American Economic Review examining college basketball point spreads and results. He found a pattern in which heavily favored teams failed to cover the spread somewhat more often than expected, and he argued that this was consistent with point shaving occurring in a small share of games involving big favorites. The study attracted attention and criticism, and other researchers questioned its interpretation. It is worth mentioning not as proof of anything but as an illustration of how difficult it is to detect shaving from the outside. A margin that comes in a little short can have a thousand innocent explanations.
The referee: Tim Donaghy
In 2007, the NBA faced the most damaging scandal in its history. The FBI had been investigating gambling networks, and its inquiry led to Tim Donaghy, a veteran NBA referee. Donaghy pleaded guilty to federal charges relating to a scheme in which he provided information about games to gamblers, including games he officiated. He was sentenced to prison in 2008, serving about a year and a quarter.
What made the case disturbing was the position of the person involved. A player can affect a game, but a referee is supposed to be the one neutral party. Donaghy had insight into things such as which referees were assigned to which games, how players and officials interacted, and the condition of players. His case turned on information, which the gamblers used to bet. The league's commissioner, David Stern, called the matter a serious blow, and said the problem was the conduct of one individual rather than a league-wide pattern. An independent review of the league's refereeing and its processes followed, and the NBA changed its monitoring of officials and its procedures for assigning and supervising them.
The Donaghy case also helped shape a debate about what a legal and regulated betting market would do for integrity. Its supporters argued that the pattern of unusual betting around Donaghy's games was the kind of thing a transparent market could flag. The league's attitude toward betting, which was hostile for decades, moved after it. Our history of legal sports betting describes how that change played out.
What the scandals have in common
Looking across seventy years of cases, several patterns appear.
- The approach is gradual. A request starts small, often described as a favor or an easy way to make money. Once a player has accepted anything, the gambler has leverage.
- The rationalization is built in. Point shaving lets a player keep believing his team is winning. That moral cover is part of why it has been so common.
- The money flows through intermediaries. A friend, a teammate, a classmate or an acquaintance who knows a gambler carries the offer. This is why investigators follow networks.
- The betting itself leaves a trail. Unusual amounts wagered on one side, or lines moving without news, can be signs of insider information. Detecting it is easier in a regulated market than in a hidden one.
- Detection is hard. Players who shave points rarely do anything blatant. The evidence tends to come from informants, wiretaps and betting records, not from the game footage.
How the sport protects itself now
Modern basketball has far more safeguards than the game of the 1950s.
- Monitoring of betting markets. Leagues, the NCAA and regulators receive reports of unusual betting patterns from licensed operators and from specialist monitoring firms. Operators are expected to flag suspicious activity, and in a licensed market, accounts are tied to verified identities.
- Rules and education. Players are banned from betting on their own sport at the professional and collegiate levels, and leagues and schools run programs that tell athletes how they might be approached and what to do if they are.
- Restrictions on certain markets. Some states prohibit bets on college players' individual performance or on games involving in-state colleges, because of the vulnerability of young amateurs.
- Officiating oversight. Leagues monitor referees' assignments and performance, review calls and keep close track of how officials behave.
- Penalties. Betting-related offenses can lead to permanent bans, criminal charges and loss of scholarships and careers.
The expansion of prop betting has created new concerns, because a bet on one player's individual numbers can be influenced by that player or by someone close to him more easily than a game result can. Regulators and leagues have been working to monitor those markets and, in some cases, to limit them. Our article on player props explains how they are set.
What to take away
Basketball's gambling scandals share a logic. The sport hands a small number of people unusual influence over a margin that can be moved quietly, and the point spread turns that margin into money. The cases of 1951, 1961, 1979 and 2007 involved different people and different mechanisms, but the same underlying vulnerability: someone with inside influence, someone with money, and a bet decided by a number.
For a fan, the lesson is not to distrust every game. It is to understand why the rules exist, why leagues care about betting data, and why players are told to stay away from wagers on their own sport. The vast majority of games are played honestly. The scandals matter because the rare exceptions did so much damage, and because the safeguards that came out of them are the reason the modern game is better protected. If you want to know more about the sport's history, our piece on the early years of basketball is a good place to start. If you would like to understand how markets work, our beginner's guide is a good primer.
Sports betting is legal only in some places and only for adults. Help lines vary by country; in the United States, the National Problem Gambling Helpline is 1-800-GAMBLER.