Knicks vs Pacers: Reggie Miller and the Garden
Six playoff series between New York and Indiana from 1993 to 2000, built around Reggie Miller, Spike Lee and Madison Square Garden, produced eight points in nine seconds and a famous finger roll.
Madison Square Garden is the most famous arena in basketball, and for most visiting players it is a place to be endured. Reggie Miller treated it as a stage. For the better part of a decade, the Indiana Pacers' shooting guard walked into New York, absorbed a building's worth of hostility, and answered it with points. He wore the crowd's hatred as if it were a tailored suit. By the end of the 1990s, a series between the Knicks and the Pacers was less a contest between teams than a morality play with Miller in the starring role and a courtside celebrity, the director Spike Lee, as his foil.
It would be easy to remember the rivalry only for its set pieces: the 25 points in a quarter, the eight points in less than nine seconds, the gesture at the front row. Those moments are worth remembering, and this article covers them. But they happened in the context of two good teams that met repeatedly in the playoffs, in series that often went the distance and that decided who would reach the NBA Finals. Between 1993 and 2000, the Knicks and Pacers met six times.
This article traces the rivalry through those six series, explains why Miller became the central figure, and describes what the rivalry meant for the way the NBA was watched in the 1990s. It also touches on the style of play that made the games tense. The Knicks' story in this era overlaps with Knicks vs Heat: the nineties playoff wars, and the two articles are best read as companions.
Two teams that suited each other
The Knicks were an established power, a franchise in the league's largest market, with a rowdy and knowledgeable fan base. In the early 1990s they were built around Patrick Ewing, a center from Georgetown, and coached by Pat Riley, who had brought a fierce defensive discipline from the Lakers. They were big, physical and nearly impossible to score against in the half-court. John Starks, Charles Oakley, Anthony Mason and Derek Harper rounded out a core that appeared in the 1994 Finals. You can read more about their leading man in the profile of Patrick Ewing.
The Pacers were something else. Indiana's franchise had been a successful team in the old American Basketball Association, winning three league titles in the 1970s before joining the NBA in 1976, and its modern incarnation was the product of patient building. Miller had been drafted from UCLA in 1987 with the 11th pick, a choice that the Indiana fans, who had wanted the local college hero Steve Alford, greeted with boos. He answered those boos over a long career spent entirely in Indianapolis, in which he became one of the greatest shooters in NBA history and a Hall of Famer. Around him the Pacers collected Rik Smits, a seven-foot-four center from the Netherlands, Dale Davis, Antonio Davis, Mark Jackson and, later, Jalen Rose, and they were coached first by Larry Brown and then, from 1997, by Larry Bird. The Pacers were deeper than they were famous, and they were tougher than their location suggested.
The matchup worked because each team's strengths aggravated the other's weaknesses. New York's defense wanted to slow the game down and grind. Indiana, with Miller running through screens and Smits scoring over smaller defenders, was patient enough to play that kind of game, and yet capable of striking quickly. The Knicks could not guard Miller without help, and Miller exploited help. The Pacers could not rebound against the Knicks' frontcourt without being fouled, and the Knicks exploited that.
1993 and 1994: the rivalry begins
They first met in the 1993 playoffs, in the first round, and the Knicks won. That was a minor chapter. The real beginning came in 1994, when the teams met in the Eastern Conference finals.
New York had just survived an exhausting seven-game series against Chicago, in a season when Michael Jordan had retired the previous fall and the Bulls were not the same team. The Knicks had home-court advantage over Indiana, and they used it. But Game 5 at the Garden became the first great chapter in the story. With the Pacers trailing, Miller scored 25 points in the fourth quarter alone, hitting jumper after jumper while Lee, seated on the baseline, taunted him from a few feet away. Miller responded by grabbing his own throat, the choke sign, at the filmmaker and at the crowd. The Pacers won the game, 93-86. The Knicks won the series, but the damage to their reputation was done: they had been outplayed in their own building by a skinny shooter with a loud mouth.
It would be inaccurate to say the Knicks lost the moral argument that year, however. They went to the Finals, where they lost a seven-game series to Houston. But Miller's performance had planted something. For the next six years, every time he stepped into the Garden, he was expected to do something outrageous, and the crowd was waiting to see if he would.
1995: eight points in 8.9 seconds
The 1995 second-round series is, by general agreement, the high point of the rivalry. It was Riley's last series as the Knicks' coach, although nobody knew it yet. The Knicks had the better record and the home-court advantage, so the first two games were played in New York, and Game 1 is the one that is still replayed.
With 18.7 seconds left, the Knicks were ahead by six points, 105-99. Miller took a pass and hit a three-pointer, bringing the Pacers within three. The Knicks tried to inbound the ball, and Miller stole the pass from Greg Anthony, backed out to the three-point line and hit a second three, tying the game at 105. In the scramble that followed, the Knicks were fouled and missed two free throws, Miller rebounded the second miss and was fouled, and he made two free throws of his own. Eight points in 8.9 seconds. The Pacers won, 107-105, and Miller spent the rest of the series as the most famous man in New York basketball.
It went to seven games. Game 7 was played in Indianapolis. The Knicks, behind Ewing, had a chance in the closing seconds: Ewing drove, put up a finger roll over a defender, and watched it rim out. The Pacers won, 97-95. Ewing's miss has remained one of the most discussed plays in the history of the franchise, not because he was a poor finisher but because he was a good one. The Pacers lost the conference finals to the Orlando Magic, but they had beaten New York, and New York had a long summer to think about it.
The late 1990s: a different kind of series
The next set of meetings was less cinematic and more important. In 1998, the Pacers, now coached by Bird in his first season, beat the Knicks in the second round in five games. It was a measured performance by a team that now understood how to win in New York. They went on to push the Chicago Bulls to seven games in the conference finals, falling short against a team that was in the middle of its last championship run.
By 1999 the roles had reversed. The Knicks, who barely made the playoffs in the lockout-shortened season, shocked Miami in the first round and Atlanta in the second, and then met Indiana in the conference finals. Ewing tore his Achilles tendon, an injury that effectively ended his time as an elite player, and the Knicks looked doomed. Instead, they won the series in six games with a patchwork lineup that relied on Allan Houston and Latrell Sprewell, and one play above all. In Game 3 at the Garden, Larry Johnson caught a pass, threw up a three-pointer with a defender, Antonio Davis, in his face, and was fouled. The ball went in. He converted the free throw. A four-point play, with 5.7 seconds left, turned a narrow deficit into a Knicks lead and gave them the game, 91-88. It was the best moment of an unlikely run, and it came against the Pacers.
The year 2000 reversed the result again. In the conference finals, the Pacers won in six games, and this time they were the team that went to the NBA Finals, the first time the franchise had reached them as an NBA club. They lost there to the Lakers, but the victory over New York was the one their fans remembered. It was also the end of the rivalry's peak. Ewing was traded that summer, Smits retired, and the two teams drifted into separate futures.
The players around the stars
Because Miller and Ewing dominate the highlights, it is easy to forget how much of the rivalry was fought by other people. Charles Oakley was the Knicks' enforcer and rebounder, a player whose job was to make life hard for anyone who came into the lane, and he took it seriously. John Starks was the opposite temperament, a fearless, streaky guard who went from undrafted free agent to All-Star and who could win a game or lose it with a single hot or cold half. Anthony Mason brought physical versatility, a forward who handled the ball like a guard, and Derek Harper brought experience at the point. Houston and Sprewell, who arrived later, supplied the scoring that Ewing's decline required.
Indiana's supporting cast was no less important. Rik Smits was an unusually mobile seven-foot-four center whose turnaround jumper from the baseline gave Ewing something to think about at the other end. Dale Davis and Antonio Davis were rebounders and screen-setters who did the unglamorous work that freed Miller. Mark Jackson, the point guard, was a bruising post-up player who slowed the game to his preferred pace and found open shooters. Brown and then Bird gave the group a steady hand, and Bird's presence in particular, a Hall of Famer who had spent his own career battling New York's best teams, lent the Pacers a certain seriousness.
These were not interchangeable role players. Each had a specific job, and the rivalry rewarded teams that knew what those jobs were. It is one reason the games were so tight: when every starter on both sides understands his assignment, the margin for error shrinks to a few possessions, and an individual burst, whether Miller's or Johnson's, can decide a series.
A look at the six series
| Year | Round | Winner | A note |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1993 | First round | Knicks | The rivalry's quiet beginning |
| 1994 | Conference finals | Knicks | Miller's 25 in the fourth quarter |
| 1995 | Second round | Pacers | Eight points in 8.9 seconds; Ewing's finger roll |
| 1998 | Second round | Pacers | Bird's first season as coach |
| 1999 | Conference finals | Knicks | Johnson's four-point play; Ewing injured |
| 2000 | Conference finals | Pacers | Indiana's first Finals trip as an NBA team |
Three wins each, and at least one of the series went the full seven games. The even split is itself a clue to why the rivalry lasted. Neither team ever dominated the other for long, and each had its moment of triumph.
Why Miller, why the Garden
The thing that made the rivalry special was the way Reggie Miller used the crowd. A weaker player might have been intimidated. Miller was an unusual combination of shooter and showman, who lived on a diet of trash talk and who seemed to play better when he was hated. He had a hard, quick release, curled off screens with an almost mechanical precision, and drew fouls with a talent for contact that infuriated defenders. He also had a willingness to say things, to opponents and to the fans, that most players kept to themselves.
It is an old truth of sports that a villain is made by an audience. Miller needed the Garden, and the Garden needed him. The crowd came to the games prepared to boo; he gave them something worth booing. Spike Lee, who sat at courtside for the Knicks, supplied the dialogue. The exchanges between them, whatever they were, delivered the sort of dramatic structure that broadcasters crave, and the television audience, in New York and beyond, responded.
There was also a deeper contrast. New York's identity was built around its defense and its fan base; Indiana's was built around a single shooter and a coherent team. Seen from a distance, the games were a meeting of two philosophies of building a contender: invest in a big market's gravitational pull, or invest in patient development of one great player. Both worked well enough to produce six memorable series.
For more on Miller himself, see Reggie Miller's career and legacy. The long histories of the two franchises are in the New York Knicks story and the Indiana Pacers story.
What the rivalry left behind
Rivalries in the NBA have often been defined by the stars involved, and this one was no exception. But its legacy is more specific than that. It showed that a player with a limited athletic profile, a wiry shooter who was not the fastest or highest-jumping player in the league, could dominate a series if he combined skill with nerve. It showed that a hostile arena could be an asset to a visiting star as well as a liability. And it demonstrated, in 1999, that a team missing its franchise center could still reach the Finals if it played with enough heart.
The rivalry also coincided with a period in which the league was learning how to turn playoff games into stories. In the 1990s, the NBA's television partners understood that the audience wanted narrative, and Miller and the Knicks gave them narrative in abundance. The best series were framed as duels, with a hero and a villain, and the crowd at the Garden was part of the show.
What to take away
If you want to understand the Knicks-Pacers rivalry, watch three things: Game 5 of the 1994 conference finals, Game 1 of the 1995 second round, and Game 3 of the 1999 conference finals. They show the rivalry's three personalities, a shooter's outburst, a collapse and a heroic play, and between them they cover most of what made the series unforgettable.
The larger lesson is about nerve. Miller, Ewing and Johnson each had a moment in which they could have shrunk and did not. The rivalry rewarded the willingness to take the shot that mattered, and it punished hesitation. For the playoff history of both teams, visit the playoffs section, and to see how either team stands in any season, check the standings.