All scores →
Loading…
Loading…
Loading…

Knicks vs Heat: the nineties playoff wars

By 4Basketball Staff · · 11 min read

Four straight playoff series between New York and Miami from 1997 to 2000, shaped by Pat Riley's move and defined by fights, one-point finishes and half-court basketball at its most punishing.

Most rivalries grow slowly, out of geography or repeated meetings. The one between the New York Knicks and the Miami Heat was born in a single afternoon in the summer of 1995, when Pat Riley, the Knicks' coach for four seasons, resigned and then turned up in Miami as the Heat's president and head coach. The Knicks were furious. The Knicks cried tampering, the two teams negotiated compensation, and a rivalry that had no history suddenly had a grievance and a villain.

What followed was one of the most physical sequences of playoff basketball the NBA has ever produced. The two teams met in the postseason four years in a row, from 1997 through 2000. The series went to full distances, produced a brawl that cost players their places in a deciding game, a famous shot that bounced off the rim and in, and a Game 7 decided by one point. The games were slow, tense and often ugly, and fans who loved them loved them for exactly those reasons. Scores in the high 70s and low 80s were normal.

This article traces how the rivalry started, how both teams were built in the image of their old coach, what happened in each of the four series, and why this period still shapes how fans remember the 1990s Eastern Conference. For background on Riley and the style he brought to both cities, see Pat Riley, Showtime, the Knicks defense and the Heat.

A resignation and a move

Riley had come to New York in 1991, after winning four championships with the Showtime Lakers, and he rebuilt the Knicks into a bruising, defense-first team. Under his coaching the Knicks reached the Eastern Conference finals in 1993, losing to Michael Jordan's Bulls, and then, in 1994, the NBA Finals, where they lost a seven-game series to Hakeem Olajuwon's Houston Rockets. The Knicks were built around Patrick Ewing, with Charles Oakley, John Starks, Anthony Mason and Derek Harper in support. They fouled, bumped, grabbed and held, and they were hard to score on, which is the foundation of Riley's approach. Many of the details of the style are described in the profile of Ewing.

Riley's relationship with the Knicks' management broke down after the 1994-95 season, in which the team was eliminated in the second round by the Indiana Pacers in a seven-game series (a rivalry of its own, covered in Knicks vs Pacers: Reggie Miller and the Garden). He faxed in his resignation, a manner many people in New York considered insulting, and a few weeks later he accepted a job in Miami as president and coach, with an ownership stake. The Knicks accused him and the Heat of tampering. The dispute was resolved when Miami agreed to compensate New York with a draft pick and cash.

For Heat fans the move was a coup. The franchise had existed only since 1988 and had made the playoffs just a few times. Within months Riley had remade it. In the 1995-96 season, he acquired Alonzo Mourning, a dominant shot-blocking center, from the Charlotte Hornets, and then Tim Hardaway, an All-Star guard with a crossover dribble known across the league, from Golden State. Mourning and Hardaway gave Miami a core, and Riley's coaching gave it an identity. The Heat played the way Riley's Knicks had: tight defense, constant physical contact, a slow tempo, and an insistence on never giving away an easy basket.

New York replaced Riley with Don Nelson, who did not last the season, and then with Jeff Van Gundy, who had been Riley's assistant for four years. That detail is the key to understanding the rivalry. Van Gundy knew Riley's playbook and Riley's habits. Both coaches built teams in the same mold, and each knew what the other would do. The games were less like a contest between styles than like a contest between two versions of the same style.

1997: the series that ended in a brawl

The first series in 1997 was the most dramatic. In the second round, the Knicks took a 3-1 lead with an experienced lineup that now included Larry Johnson, a former star forward, and Allan Houston, a shooting guard who had signed as a free agent. Miami, led by Mourning, Hardaway, Jamal Mashburn and the physical forward P.J. Brown, had been the higher seed, but New York appeared to have found control.

Then came Game 5 in Miami. In the closing seconds, Charlie Ward, the Knicks' point guard, and the Heat's P.J. Brown tangled, and Brown grabbed Ward and flipped him over his back to the floor. Benches emptied. When the dust settled, the league handed down suspensions, and because players had left the bench area during the fight, the rule that governs such moments came into effect. Several Knicks starters, including Ewing, were suspended for the next game or games, while Brown also received a suspension of his own. The suspensions hit New York harder than they hit Miami, because the Knicks were the team with the advantage in the series and the lineup on the floor was suddenly missing key players.

Miami won Game 5, then Game 6 in New York, and finished off the comeback in Game 7 in Miami, 101-90. A team that had led 3-1 lost three games in a row. For years afterward New York fans pointed to the rule on leaving the bench, and the way it had been applied, as a sort of injustice. The Heat, for their part, saw the result as proof that Riley had built a team that was at least as hard as the one he had left. They advanced to the conference finals, where they lost to Chicago in five games.

1998: a series that almost didn't finish

The next year they met in the first round, which at that time was a best-of-five series. Miami was the second seed and New York was the seventh, but the series was close from the start. The memorable moment came in Game 4, when Larry Johnson and Mourning, both strong and short-tempered, began fighting during a stoppage. Within seconds the court was crowded with players and coaches. In the middle of the scrum, Van Gundy, who was much smaller than the athletes around him, threw himself onto Mourning's leg and clung to it as the larger man tried to move through the crowd. The image of the coach holding on to the center's leg became one of the lasting snapshots of the 1990s NBA, both comic and a little sad.

The Knicks won the series in five games. The aftermath was typical of the rivalry: suspensions, fines and an ongoing sense of grievance on both sides. But the series also established something important. New York no longer dreaded Miami. Miami, for its part, understood that being the higher seed did not entitle it to anything against a team that had faced the same tests.

1999: Houston's shot

The 1998-99 season was shortened to 50 games by the lockout, and the Knicks barely made the playoffs, entering as the eighth seed. They were thought to be a declining team. Ewing was aging, Starks had been traded, and Latrell Sprewell had arrived from Golden State. Their first-round opponent was Miami, the top seed in the East, and the series went to five games again.

It was decided in the last second of the last game. In Game 5 in Miami, with the Knicks trailing by one and a few ticks on the clock, Allan Houston took a pass and shot a floater over a defender. The ball hit the front of the rim, bounced up to the backboard, fell back and dropped through the net, with 0.8 seconds left. The Knicks won, 78-77. It was one of the great shots in playoff history because of how little the ball needed to do. A fraction of an inch, and Miami would have advanced.

The aftermath was even stranger. New York, the eighth seed, kept going. They beat Atlanta in the next round and then, with Ewing lost to a torn Achilles tendon during the conference finals, they beat Indiana, thanks in large part to a four-point play by Larry Johnson in Game 3. They became the first eighth-seeded team in NBA history to reach the Finals, though they lost there to the San Antonio Spurs. The win over Miami was the opening of that run.

2000: the last one

The fourth meeting, in the 2000 second round, felt like a farewell. Both teams were aging, and their approach was starting to look like an anachronism. The league's scoring averages had fallen throughout the decade, partly because of the physicality both teams embodied, and some critics called the style unwatchable. The series gave them an answer: seven games of tension that few viewers would have called boring. New York won Game 7 by a single point, 83-82, in another game that came down to a last possession. It was the third time in four years that a series between them was decided by a margin of a few points.

The Knicks went on to lose to the Pacers in the conference finals, in six games. That summer, Ewing was traded to Seattle, ending a 15-year career in New York. Mourning, a few months later, was diagnosed with a serious kidney condition. He returned to the court after a transplant in 2003, and in 2006 he was part of a Heat team that won the first championship in franchise history, with Riley again on the sideline. The rivalry's first act ended with the departure of its two central figures, and it has never quite been matched since.

How the two teams actually played

It helps to picture a typical possession in these series. The offense walked the ball up and, more often than not, fed a big man on the block. For New York that was Ewing, a patient post scorer whose turnaround jumper from the elbow and baseline was one of the most reliable shots of the era. For Miami it was Mourning, who was quicker and more explosive and the more terrifying shot-blocker of the two. Each team then asked its perimeter players to cut, screen and wait. If the first option was taken away, the ball swung to a shooter, Houston for the Knicks or Hardaway and Mashburn for the Heat, and the possession often ended with a contested jumper late on the shot clock.

Defense was where the teams distinguished themselves. Both played a style built on denying the ball, bumping cutters, fighting through every screen and sending a second defender at the post. The rules of the time allowed a defender to keep a hand or forearm on a ball-handler far more than they do today, and Riley's teams used every inch of that allowance. The result was a game with little flow, in which a ten-point lead felt enormous. It is why a single shot by Houston could decide a series, and why a Game 7 could be decided by one point.

It also explains why the fights happened. When every possession involves contact, tempers rise, and when every game could end a season, the penalties for losing one's temper feel smaller than the penalties for backing down. Neither coach was shy about that. Both teams had enforcers, Oakley and Larry Johnson in New York, Brown and Mourning in Miami, and both had players who understood that the quickest way to mark territory was to be the first to strike. That is not an endorsement. It is an explanation, and a reminder that the league was still working out where the lines should be.

A ledger of the four series

Year Round Winner Series A note
1997 Second round Heat 4-3 Game 5 brawl; Knicks lost a 3-1 lead
1998 First round Knicks 3-2 Johnson and Mourning fight; Van Gundy on the floor
1999 First round Knicks 3-2 Houston's shot in Game 5, 78-77
2000 Second round Knicks 4-3 Game 7 decided 83-82

New York won three of the four. But the aggregate hides how close each series was: over twenty-four games, the margin between the teams was small, and the result of nearly every series depended on a single possession.

Why it mattered

The rivalry mattered for reasons larger than its results. The first was its effect on the way the league was played. The Knicks and Heat were the extreme example of a style that dominated the East in the 1990s: slow, defensive, physical, with scores that would later seem startlingly low. It was not an accident. Both teams were coached by a man who believed that the way to win in the playoffs was to make every possession difficult, and who had the personnel to do it. The league's later rule changes, which curbed hand-checking and loosened the restrictions on zone defense, partly reflected an urge to move away from the version of basketball that these teams played so well.

The second is what it shows about how rivalries are made. We tend to think a rivalry needs a great history. This one had no history until Riley left, and then it produced four classic series in a row. What it needed was two good teams with a shared grievance, a similar philosophy, and a reason to make each game matter. The grudge gave the games an edge that fans could feel, and the similarities guaranteed that neither side had a clear advantage.

The third is the human dimension. The images that stay from these series are not strategic. They are Van Gundy on the floor, Houston's shot on the rim, the Knicks trying to play Game 6 without several of their starters. Sports memory is made of such moments, and the best rivalries give the audience plenty of them.

For the histories of each franchise, see the New York Knicks story and the Miami Heat story. The decade they played in is described in the 1990s: the Dream Team, expansion and the lockout.

What to take away

If you want to understand why the 1990s Eastern Conference looked the way it did, watch these four series. They show that a team can be dominant without being beautiful, and that grinding basketball can be thrilling if the stakes are high enough. They also show that a rivalry can be created by a single decision, and that when it is, the people involved will fill in the rest.

To follow either franchise's playoff history, visit the playoffs section, and for where they stood in any given season, see the standings.

Search more on this

Keep reading

Knicks vs Pacers: Reggie Miller and the Garden

Six playoff series between New York and Indiana from 1993 to 2000, built around Reggie Miller, Spike Lee and Madison Square Garden, produced eight points in nine seconds and a famous finger roll.

4Basketball Staff · Sep 24, 2026 · 10 min read