Villanova, Georgetown and the Big East's Catholic schools
Why so many of the Big East's basketball powers were Catholic urban universities, how Georgetown and Villanova rose within the league, and what the 2013 split showed about the schools that built the conference.
When the Big East was formed in 1979, its founders wanted a basketball conference for the eastern cities, a league of schools that cared more about the game than about football. Many of the members they gathered shared another trait: they were Catholic universities, founded by religious orders, located in or near major cities, and fiercely proud of their basketball teams. Within a few years the league was the most talked-about conference in the country, and two of its Catholic schools, Georgetown and Villanova, had won national championships against each other, one in the shadow of a famous upset.
This article looks at that story. It explains how Georgetown became a national power under John Thompson, how Villanova beat the Hoyas in a final that is still remembered as one of the great upsets, and how the Catholic schools shaped the league's identity, including the dramatic split of 2013 that brought it back to its roots. It is a story about institutions as much as about players: why certain kinds of schools thrive in basketball, how a conference becomes a brand, and what happens when the economics of college sports pull it apart.
Why Catholic schools and basketball fit together
The connection between Catholic universities and basketball is not an accident, and it is worth understanding. Many of these schools were founded in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries to serve immigrant communities in cities such as New York, Philadelphia, Boston, Providence and Washington. They were urban, often commuter-oriented and relatively small. And most of them did not field major football programs, which are expensive and need large campuses and stadiums.
Basketball was the opposite. It could be played indoors, in the winter, in an urban gymnasium, with a small roster and modest facilities. It was a sport that city kids played, and a Catholic school with a good team could draw a large local following and attract attention from the press. For schools without a football team to anchor their identity, basketball became the main source of visibility and alumni pride. The same logic applied to Catholic high schools, many of which developed strong teams that fed players into the colleges.
The result was a group of schools that saw basketball as central to their mission to a degree that larger football-driven institutions did not. When a conference was created to bring them together, the combination of local pride and a shared focus on the sport produced an unusually intense atmosphere.
The founding of the Big East
The Big East was the creation of Dave Gavitt, the athletic director and former basketball coach at Providence. Gavitt saw that the eastern basketball schools were scattered among different arrangements, with many playing as independents, and that a conference could give them a stronger schedule, a television package and a postseason tournament. In 1979 he brought together seven schools: Syracuse, Georgetown, St. John's, Providence, Boston College, Seton Hall and Connecticut. Villanova joined the following year.
The league moved quickly to take advantage of television. Its games appeared on regional and national networks, and its conference tournament, held at Madison Square Garden from 1983, became a major event. By the mid-1980s the Big East had a reputation as the toughest league in the country, and in 1985 it put three teams in the Final Four: Georgetown, St. John's and Villanova. The full story of the conference is told in the Big East's history from the 1979 founding to today.
John Thompson and the Georgetown rise
The most important program in the early Big East was Georgetown, and the most important person was John Thompson Jr. When he was hired in 1972, the Hoyas had just finished 3-23. Thompson, a former Boston Celtics reserve and a successful high school coach in Washington, had a clear idea of how to build a program. He recruited players from the city and from across the country, prized defense and discipline, and projected an image of toughness that opponents found intimidating. He was recognizable on the sideline for the white towel he carried over his shoulder.
Thompson's teams played a physical, pressuring man-to-man defense that smothered opponents. The Hoyas' style could look severe, and some critics complained that it bordered on intimidation. But it was extremely effective, and the arrival of Patrick Ewing, a seven-foot center from Cambridge, Massachusetts, in 1981 turned a good program into a great one. Ewing was a dominant shot blocker and a powerful presence in the lane, and his career is covered in the profile of Patrick Ewing.
With Ewing, Georgetown reached the national championship game in 1982, losing 63-62 to North Carolina on a late jump shot by freshman Michael Jordan, a game described in North Carolina basketball. Two years later, in 1984, the Hoyas won the title, beating Houston, a team that featured Hakeem Olajuwon, in the final. Thompson became the first Black head coach to win the NCAA men's championship, a milestone whose significance was widely noted at the time and has been recalled many times since.
Thompson was also a public figure outside basketball. In January 1989, he walked off the court before a game to protest an NCAA rule, known as Proposition 42, that would have denied athletic scholarships to certain academically at-risk freshmen. His action was a statement of principle, drawing attention to what he saw as a rule that disproportionately harmed Black athletes from poor schools. It was one of several moments in which Thompson used his platform to raise questions about the structure of college sports.
1985: the perfect game
The Hoyas returned to the final in 1985, and they were heavy favorites. They had won 35 games, still had Ewing and had beaten most opponents easily. Their opponent was Villanova, an eight seed from the same conference, which had needed to scrape through the tournament to reach the final in Lexington, Kentucky.
Villanova's coach was Rollie Massimino, a charismatic tactician. He devised a plan to control the tempo, using a patient offense that took a shot only when it was open, working against the Georgetown defense. The Wildcats shot almost perfectly, hitting nearly every field goal they took, and they held on at the end to win 66-64. It was an upset of the highest order, and it remains a standard example of how a well-prepared underdog can win a one-game final. The full account is in the 1985 Villanova upset of Georgetown.
The game had a mathematical lesson as well. An underdog that can limit possessions and play near-flawless basketball for 40 minutes has a better chance of winning than its season record suggests, an idea explored in why upsets happen. Villanova's win gave it its first national title and made 1985 the high-water mark of the Big East's early years.
Villanova's second life under Jay Wright
After Massimino left in 1992, Villanova remained a solid program but did not return to the sport's top tier for years. The turn came under Jay Wright, who took over in 2001. Wright's teams were built on guards who could shoot and defend, and he took an approach of recruiting players who would stay several years and develop. This was a contrast to the one-and-done model prevalent at other schools, a theme covered in the one-and-done era.
The Wildcats reached the Final Four in 2009 and then, in 2016, won the national championship. The final was against North Carolina, and it ended with one of the most dramatic finishes in the history of the event: after the Tar Heels tied the game with a late three-pointer, Villanova's Kris Jenkins took a pass at the top of the arc and made a shot as time expired, winning 77-74. Two years later, in 2018, Villanova won again, beating Michigan 79-62 behind the scoring of Donte DiVincenzo off the bench and the play of Jalen Brunson, the national player of the year. The shot is included among the buzzer-beaters in March Madness.
Wright retired in 2022 with two national titles and a reputation for running one of the most respected programs in the country. The Wildcats' success under him is a case study in program-building through stability, as covered in coaches who built NCAA tournament dynasties.
The other Catholic schools
Georgetown and Villanova are the best known, but the other Catholic members shaped the league just as much.
- St. John's, in Queens, was coached for decades by Lou Carnesecca and featured Chris Mullin, the national player of the year in 1985. The Red Storm made the Final Four that year and gave the league its connection to the New York market, with home games that also appeared at Madison Square Garden.
- Seton Hall, in New Jersey, reached the national title game in 1989 under P.J. Carlesimo, losing in overtime to Michigan.
- Providence, the school of the league's founder, reached the Final Four in 1987 under Rick Pitino, the same coach who later led Kentucky and Louisville.
- Boston College, a Jesuit school like Georgetown, was a founding member and stayed until it left for the Atlantic Coast Conference in 2005.
- Marquette and DePaul joined the Big East in 2005. Marquette had won the 1977 national title under Al McGuire, in his last game as a coach, and DePaul had been a national name under Ray Meyer in the 1970s and 1980s.
What these schools shared was a size and a setting. Most had a few thousand undergraduates, a city location and an athletic budget that could support a strong basketball program but not a major football operation. They also shared a way of using the sport: as the school's public face, a chance for alumni and neighborhoods to see themselves in the team. The Big East's culture, with its raucous Garden tournament and its rivalries among nearby campuses, grew out of those conditions.
The Garden and the tournament
No account of the league is complete without Madison Square Garden. From 1983 the conference tournament was played there, and it grew into one of the signature events of the college calendar: four days of games in the middle of Manhattan, with fan bases arriving by train from Providence, Philadelphia and Washington, and a ticket that doubled as a rite of spring. Winning the tournament was a title that players cherished in its own right, and it was a launching pad for the NCAA tournament that followed.
The Garden has produced epic games, and the longest of them is a Big East legend. In the 2009 quarterfinals, Syracuse beat Connecticut 127-117 in six overtimes, a game that lasted well past midnight and ended with both teams exhausted. It remains one of the longest games in the history of major-college basketball. It also shows what the building meant: a place where the league's rivalries played out in front of a crowd that knew the sport and expected a fight. The tradition survived the 2013 split, because the new conference kept the tournament at the Garden.
The 2013 split
The Big East's first form did not last. In the 2000s and early 2010s, conferences were reorganized around football television money, and the Big East, with its mix of football-playing and non-football members, was pulled in different directions. Syracuse, Pittsburgh and Louisville left for the Atlantic Coast Conference, West Virginia went to the Big 12, and the league's structure came apart. The story is explained in conference realignment and basketball.
The seven Catholic schools that did not play major-college football, DePaul, Georgetown, Marquette, Providence, Seton Hall, St. John's and Villanova, decided in 2013 to leave and form a new league that would keep the Big East name and the tournament at Madison Square Garden. They added Butler, Xavier and Creighton, three schools with strong basketball traditions, to fill out the membership. The old league's football-playing members, among them Connecticut and Cincinnati, formed what became the American Athletic Conference.
The new Big East was, in effect, a return to the original idea: a conference of urban schools that care primarily about basketball. It also changed the competitive picture, because the league became one where basketball revenue and attention were the main measures of success. The results were soon visible. Villanova won its two national titles in 2016 and 2018 in the new league, and Connecticut returned to the Big East in 2020 after years in the American. The new conference demonstrated that a league built around basketball could remain nationally relevant.
What Georgetown became
Georgetown's story after Thompson is a mix of continuity and change. John Thompson resigned in 1999, with nearly 600 wins and a place in the Hall of Fame. His son, John Thompson III, coached the team from 2004 and led it to the Final Four in 2007. Patrick Ewing returned to coach his alma mater in 2017. The program has remained a prominent name, though it has not reached the heights of the 1980s. The Hoyas' history also includes Allen Iverson, who played two seasons in the 1990s and left for the NBA as a first overall pick, a career summarized in Allen Iverson's profile, as well as Alonzo Mourning and Dikembe Mutombo, two of the great shot blockers in the sport's history.
Reading the Catholic school model
The Catholic-school basketball model has strengths and limits that help to explain why these programs rise and fall.
- Strengths. A clear identity, urban recruiting bases, an alumni network that pays attention to basketball, and a conference in which every game matters.
- Limits. Small enrollments and modest athletic budgets, little football revenue to cushion a down cycle, and the challenge of competing for recruits against larger programs with bigger facilities.
The best Catholic-school programs have usually managed the tradeoff through good coaching. Thompson, Massimino, Carnesecca, McGuire and Wright all built programs that outperformed their resources, and the pattern suggests that in college basketball, culture and stability can be as important as money. The point is made across the sport, as in the article on mid-major basketball.
What to take away
The Big East's Catholic schools built a conference from a shared set of circumstances: urban settings, modest sizes, no major football and a passion for basketball. Georgetown showed that a program could be rebuilt around defense and toughness, Villanova showed that a patient underdog could win on the biggest stage, and the 2013 split showed that the schools understood what the league was for.
For fans, these programs are a reminder that basketball tradition does not belong only to the largest universities. To follow the league and the teams in it, see the college section and the standings.