All scores →
Loading…
Loading…
Loading…

The Original Celtics and the barnstorming era

By 4Basketball Staff · · 10 min read

The story of the New York team that dominated professional basketball in the 1920s, how barnstorming kept the sport alive between leagues, and what the Original Celtics invented, including switching defense and the pivot play.

Before there was an NBA, before there was a stable professional league of any kind, there were teams that traveled. They played in town halls, armories, dance floors and high school gyms, often several nights in a row, against local opponents who hoped to beat the famous visitors. They were called barnstormers, a word borrowed from the farmers' fields where early aviators and traveling performers put on shows. The most famous basketball barnstormers were a New York team called the Original Celtics, and for the better part of a decade in the 1920s they were as close to a professional dynasty as the sport had.

The Celtics deserve attention for two reasons. The first is competitive. They won at a rate that no professional team since has matched, and they did it against the best opponents available. The second is intellectual. They played a smarter game than their rivals, and several of the things they did, from passing patterns to a switching defense, became part of the sport's permanent vocabulary. Their story also tells you a good deal about the economics of the early game, why the leagues of the time kept collapsing, and how a travelling business shaped the sport for decades.

Why barnstorming existed

To understand the Original Celtics, you have to understand the world they played in. In the 1910s and 1920s, professional basketball had no stable structure. There were leagues, but they were regional, short-lived and poorly capitalized. Players frequently changed teams in the middle of a season, sometimes for a better offer and sometimes simply because a different team was playing that night. A good player might be listed on several rosters at once. The schedule consisted of whatever games promoters could arrange.

In that environment, a strong independent team could make a living by traveling. A promoter in a small town would book a famous team to play the local club on a Saturday night, rent a hall, and sell tickets. The visiting team would take a share of the gate. The more famous the visitors, the larger the crowd, and the larger the share. A team that won every night developed a reputation, and a reputation drew crowds. The financial logic favored winning, which meant that the best barnstormers had a strong incentive to recruit the best players, and to keep them.

The conditions were hard. Teams traveled by train and car, often arriving at night and playing the next day. The halls were of uneven quality, with floors that were sometimes slick with wax from a previous dance and baskets that were sometimes off center. Games were often played inside wire or rope cages, which kept the ball in play and kept fans from touching the players. In some towns, the home team's supporters were hostile, and the visitors had to be careful about referees. A barnstorming team played a heavy schedule, often more than a hundred games a season, and it did not have the luxury of rest. The players who thrived were those who combined skill with durability.

Who the Original Celtics were

The team took shape in New York around 1914, in the neighborhoods on the city's west side, and was organized by a manager named Jim Furey. Over the years, the roster included some of the best players in the game. The lineup that came to define the team in the early 1920s featured Nat Holman, a quick, clever guard who was known for his passing and ball handling and who would go on to a long career as a college coach at City College of New York; Joe Lapchick, a tall center who later coached St. John's University and the New York Knicks; Dutch Dehnert, a heavy, powerful big man credited with developing the pivot play; Johnny Beckman, a prolific scorer; and others including Pete Barry and Chris Leonard. They were a mix of skills and temperaments, and the way they played together was the key to their success.

The Boston Celtics, founded in 1946, took the name as a tribute, and it carries a trace of the barnstormers' prestige, a subject covered in the Boston Celtics franchise story.

A team that won almost everything

The records from the period are incomplete and inconsistent, so it is best to describe the Celtics' dominance in general terms. They won the great majority of their games across several seasons, often losing only a handful of times in a year, and in a few cases they reportedly won more than nine of every ten. The numbers quoted in popular accounts vary, and not all of them can be verified, but every source agrees on the basic point: they were by far the best team of their time, and a significant part of their appeal was that they almost never lost.

They played against all kinds of opponents. Local teams in small towns, college stars, other professional clubs, and the best independent teams in the country all met them. Some of their most memorable contests were with the New York Renaissance, the Black professional team known as the Rens, who were among the few teams capable of beating them. The Rens and the Celtics played a series of games in the 1920s that drew large crowds and were taken as a test of the best white and Black teams in the game. The Rens won some of them, which was a significant achievement given the odds they faced in the era. The Rens' story is told in Black basketball pioneers: the Rens, the Globetrotters and the integration of the pro game.

What they invented

What makes the Original Celtics more than a record-holder is that they played smarter basketball. Three contributions are widely credited to them, with the usual caveat that early basketball history is hard to document precisely.

  1. Switching defense. Most teams in the early 1920s played a strict man-to-man defense in which each defender followed his opponent wherever he went. The Celtics are credited with popularizing the switch, in which two defenders exchange assignments when an offensive player screens one of them. The idea is simple and now standard, but at the time it was an innovation that confounded teams accustomed to straightforward cuts and screens. Today, switching is a basic defensive tool, and its extreme form is analyzed in switch-everything defense and its weakness.
  2. The pivot play. Dutch Dehnert is credited with the center pivot, in which a big man positioned near the free-throw line received passes and acted as a hub for the offense. Teammates cut around him, taking handoffs or receiving passes for layups. The pivot play is the ancestor of the post offense, the high post, and even the modern dribble handoff, and its descendants include the elbow offense.
  3. Ball movement. Holman and his teammates favored crisp passing and constant motion, a style that depended on all five players understanding the same system. Their offense was built on the cut, the give-and-go and the quick pass, ideas that remain at the heart of the game, as the discussion of motion offense shows.

There is an insight in all three that goes beyond the details. The Celtics were not simply more talented than their opponents; they were more organized. In an era when many teams relied on one or two stars taking most of the shots, the Celtics distributed the ball and the work. Their players were interchangeable in some respects, and that depth gave them resilience. The lesson, which later champions would rediscover repeatedly, is that systems beat individuals when talent is roughly equal.

The American Basketball League

By the mid-1920s, professional basketball had grown enough that a serious league looked possible. The American Basketball League began play in 1925, bringing together teams from the East and Midwest in an attempt to build an organized schedule and a recognized champion. The Original Celtics joined for the 1926-27 season, and the effect was dramatic. They were by far the best team in the league and won the title. The effect of such dominance on the league was mixed. On one hand, the Celtics drew crowds, because fans wanted to see the famous team. On the other, a league in which one team always wins soon loses the suspense that sells tickets, and other clubs complained about being reduced to opponents in the Celtics' show.

The league's response was a recurring theme in the history of professional sports: how to keep a competitive balance when one team is far stronger than the rest. The Celtics' stars were eventually spread around, in effect, and the team that emerged from the shuffle was less dominant. Over the next few years the league struggled with the same issues that had undermined its predecessors, including costs, travel and the economic pressure of the Great Depression, and the original ABL suspended play in the early 1930s. A later version of the league existed for decades, but it never recaptured the prominence of its first years. The barnstormers returned to the road.

The barnstorming business in the Depression years

The 1930s were hard on professional basketball. The Depression drained attendance, and most of the pro leagues of the decade were small and short-lived. In this environment, barnstorming survived because it was cheap and flexible. A traveling team did not need a league, a stadium or a salary structure; it needed a few good players, a car and a willing promoter. The Celtics themselves continued to play in various forms, and other traveling teams filled the space. Among them were the Harlem Globetrotters, who began in Chicago in the 1920s and became a world-famous attraction, and the Rens, who continued to dominate the Black professional circuit. Another was the Philadelphia SPHAS, a team associated with the city's Jewish community, which played in a league and on the road. These teams were more than curiosities. They kept the game visible in an era when little else did.

The barnstormers also had an impact on the style of the game. They traveled widely and played against many opponents, and they carried their innovations with them. A coach in a small town who watched the Celtics might copy their switching defense or their passing patterns, and so the barnstormers served as a kind of unofficial teaching tour. The Celtics' influence spread beyond their own roster, through the players who became coaches. Holman at City College of New York coached teams that played an up-tempo, pass-oriented game, and in 1950 his team won both the National Invitation Tournament and the NCAA tournament in the same year, an achievement no other team has matched. Lapchick coached at St. John's and later with the Knicks. In this way, the lessons of the barnstorming era flowed into both college and professional basketball.

How the era ended

The decline of barnstorming came in two stages. First, in the late 1930s, new leagues arose in the Midwest, especially the National Basketball League, which was founded in 1937 and drew its teams from industrial companies in cities such as Akron, Fort Wayne and Oshkosh. These were stable operations, with company sponsors who paid players and provided jobs. They offered a more reliable living than the road. Second, after the Second World War, new leagues with larger ambitions appeared, notably the Basketball Association of America, founded in 1946 by the owners of major arenas who wanted to fill their buildings with something besides hockey. Their story is told in the Basketball Association of America and the NBA's 1949 merger.

Once there were regular leagues with schedules, standings and playoffs, the independent barnstormer had less to offer. A fan in a city with a BAA team could see better players on a predictable schedule. The great barnstormers adapted: the Globetrotters turned to entertainment and international tours, and others folded or became part of the new structures. By 1950, the age of the independent team had mostly ended. But its legacy lasted. The leagues that replaced it were built on the principle that the best teams should play each other repeatedly, and they relied on stars who had been made famous on the road.

What the Original Celtics left behind

It is easy to treat the Original Celtics as a curiosity, a team of old-timers in baggy shorts. That would miss their significance. They showed that basketball could be played as a team game, that defense could be as creative as offense, and that a professional team could be a public draw. They demonstrated that a sport without a stable league could still produce stars and a following. And they gave the Boston franchise a name that would eventually be associated with the winningest team in NBA history, as explored in Red Auerbach and the Celtics system.

What to take away

If you remember one idea about the Original Celtics, make it this: they won because they thought about the game differently. Their switching defense, their pivot-centered offense and their commitment to ball movement were ideas ahead of their time, and they were taken up by coaches at every level. If you remember a second idea, make it the importance of the barnstorming era as a bridge. Between the amateur origins of the sport and the modern NBA, there was a long period in which professional basketball survived on the road, and the teams that did it laid the groundwork for what followed. To see how the sport's structure developed from there, continue with the early years of the game or visit the teams section to explore franchises old and new.

Search more on this

Keep reading

Willis Reed's entrance: Game 7 of the 1970 Finals

The story of Game 7 of the 1970 NBA Finals, when an injured Willis Reed walked out of the Madison Square Garden tunnel, scored the first points and lifted the Knicks to their first championship.

4Basketball Staff · Jul 8, 2026 · 11 min read

The 1990s: the Dream Team, expansion and the lockout

The 1990s saw the NBA become a worldwide product, add franchises in new cities, lose part of a season to a lockout and hand the game from Jordan's Bulls to a new generation. Here is how the decade unfolded.

4Basketball Staff · Jun 24, 2026 · 11 min read